Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
Subject: Arms Research Partnerships FOI Request 2026
To whom it may concern,
Thank you for your assistance with my previous request in April 2026 (Arms Investments). Please find below a separate request under the Freedom of Information Act of 2000.
In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
This is limited to the following companies:
-
BAE Systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon (RTX)
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Northrop Grumman
-
L3 Harris Technologies
-
General Electric
-
AVIC
-
GKN Aerospace
-
Boeing
-
Ministry of Defence (MoD)
-
Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (DSTL)
-
Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
In the below request, the phrase ‘research project' is related, but not limited to:
Any academic research collaborations that involve (as partner/funder/collaborator) university students or staff conducting research with the above-listed arms trade companies'.
Please limit the search to information held within the Research Services and the Finance Division (Research Accounts).
This includes the following activities:
- Sponsored, Commissioned, or Collaborative Research Projects
- Any research project, programme, consortium, or contract
- Research Centres, Institutes, Laboratories
- Any research centre or department, doctoral training centre, or similar research structure
- Student, Doctoral, Innovation, or Applied Research Arrangements
- Studentships, professorships and fellowships for the purpose of conducting specific research
2) Name of the department or school where the information is located. - a) If the information requested in Question 1 is located centrally, for example, within the Careers or Student Futures department, please identify the department, faculty, research unit, administrative office, or other part of the university that stores or manages the relevant information for each category listed. - b) If any part of the information requested in Question 1 is not located centrally, please specify which parts are not held centrally and identify the department, faculty, research unit, administrative office, or other part of the university that stores, manages, or is otherwise most likely to have the relevant information. For example, information related to apprenticeships is held by individual schools or subject departments.
Thank you kindly,
Houcine Doukani
/----------------------
Clarification of Request:
Dear Officer,
Thank you for confirming receipt of my request. Please the clarification requested in bold under each bullet point :
- The categories of information you are requesting;
1) Sponsored, Commissioned, or Collaborative Research Projects - Any research project, programme, consortium, or contract
2) Research Centres, Institutes, Laboratories - Any research centre or department, doctoral training centre, or similar research structure
3) Student, Doctoral, Innovation, or Applied Research Arrangements - Studentships, professorships and fellowships for the purpose of conducting specific research
- the date range the request should cover;
01 August 2024 - to - Date of request (05th August 2026)
- whether you are seeking active arrangements only;
Seeking activities that began within the timeframe specified in the request (above). The project doesn't need to be currently active but must begin within the request time-frame.
I trust that I have sufficiently clarified this request.
Thank you kindly,
Houcine
/----------------------
Clarification of Request 2:
Dear Officer,
Thankyou for requesting further clarification, and bringing this to my attention, this information was somehow accidentally not make it into the original request. Please accept my sincerest apologies for this oversight. Please find my response in bold underneath your query:
Query: We believe we understand the records the scope should cover, but are still not fully clear on the specific scope. For instance, we may be able to return the names of any projects that fall under these categories and timescales, if they are held, if that is what you are looking to obtain?
Answer: For each activity that falls under the request and timescales of this request please provide the following information: - i. The title and descriptions of the purpose of the partnership and academic department(s) involved - ii. The partners and source of funding (to be included, an arms company can be either a partner or funder of the partnership) - iv. Academic years, including the start and end date (DD-MM-YY) of the partnership or funding. - v. Total amount in GBP provided for each partnership - vi. Other participating UK universities and the nature of their involvement (partner, collaborator, funder).
Kind Regards,
Houcine Doukani
/----------------------
Follow-up Request:
Dear Officer,
I am writing to inform you that the 20-working-day statutory timeframe for the original request has now passed, and a notice of delay was not received from the University within this timeframe. Please a provide a response by the 29th September 2026.
Best Wishes,
Houcine Doukani
Response Refusal Reason
All requested details were withheld. For the MoD and AWE, the university confirmed it holds information but withheld it under s24(1) (national security, citing the 'mosaic effect') and s26(1)(a)(b) (defence). For Rolls-Royce, it confirmed collaboration and funding but withheld values, titles and collaborators under s43(2) (commercial interests) and s41 (information provided in confidence, as Rolls-Royce considers disclosure an actionable breach of confidence). Public interest tests favoured withholding.
Response Text
Please find attached the University's response to your request.
I write in reply to your email requesting the information detailed above.
Background We have established that of the 23 companies/organisations listed in your request, the University has received research funding within the period and scope covered by your request.
When we receive a request for information relating to an external organisation, it is our standard procedure to consult that organisation before responding, in case it considers any of the information to be exempt from disclosure. We therefore apologise for the delay in responding to your request, which was partly as a result of the consultation exercise.
Section 24 – National Security
As regards the MOD and AWE, the University confirms that it holds information falling within the scope of your request. Based on the representations made to us, the University is satisfied that this information is exempt from disclosure under section 24(1) of the FOIA. Section 24(1) provides that information is exempt from disclosure for the purpose of safeguarding national security.
The exemption in section 24 is a qualified exemption that requires the University to weigh the public interest in disclosing the information requested, which is presumed from the FOIA, against the public interest in maintaining the exemption.
We recognise that there is a public interest in disclosing details of research the University undertakes with funding from Governmental defence-related bodies, as a better knowledge and understanding will increase confidence in the Government’s work in this area, and provide transparency.
Nevertheless, we feel that the public interest is better served by withholding the information. This is because the information, if released, could be pieced together with information from other Higher Education Providers or other collaborators of these organisations; data released about the in particular MOD is known to be scraped and, when aggregated and assimilated over time, provides adversaries with a rich picture of defence interest, even with redaction, due to the mosaic effect. The mosaic effect is defined on the ICO website, and means that on its own the requested information might not be harmful. However, if disclosed, it could be pieced together with other information already known, and increase the likelihood of prejudice. Over time, it is possible that disclosure of this information could result in a significant threat to national security, as it could allow adversaries to target the MOD’s suppliers for intelligence gathering activities and/or cause disruption, especially through the use of non-traditional techniques such as cyber-attack.
For these reasons, we believe that disclosing the requested information would be detrimental to national security, and consequently is not in the public interest. We believe that the public interest is adequately addressed by the information published online about AWE and MOD’s Area of Research Interest, on the www.gov.uk website.
Section 26 – Defence
Similarly, the University also considers that information relating to the MOD and AWE is exempt from disclosure under s.26(1)(a) and (b) of the FOIA. Section 26(1) provides that information is exempt from disclosure if said disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the defence of the British Islands or of any colony, s.26(1)(a), or the capability, effectiveness or security of any relevant forces, s.26(1)(b). Relevant forces are defined in section 26(2)(a) – the armed forces of the Crown, and (b), any forces co-operating with those forces.
The MOD falls under section 26(2)(b), and so the exemption is engaged. Based on the representations made to us, the University is satisfied that disclosure would be likely to prejudice both the defence of the British Islands or of any colony, and the capability, effectiveness or security of any relevant forces.
We recognise that there is a public interest in disclosing details of research the University undertakes with funding from Governmental defence-related bodies, as a better knowledge and understanding will increase confidence in the Government’s work in this area, and provide transparency. However, we feel that the public interest is better served by withholding the information. We consider that the requested information could allow adversaries to target the MOD’s suppliers for intelligence gathering activities and/or cause disruption, especially through the use of non-traditional techniques such as cyber-attack, which would be harmful to the defence of the British Islands and its colonies. The information, if released, could be pieced together with information from other Higher Education Providers or other collaborators of the MOD; the data is known to be scraped and, when aggregated and assimilated over time, provides adversaries with a rich picture of defence interest and capability even with redaction, due to the mosaic effect, as described above.
For these reasons, we believe that disclosing the requested information would be detrimental to the defence of the British Islands and its colonies, and the capability, effectiveness, and security of any relevant forces, and consequently is not in the public interest. We believe, as listed above section 24, that the public interest is adequately addressed by the information published online about AWE and MOD’s Area of Research Interest, on the www.gov.uk website.
Section 43(2) – Prejudice to commercial interests
The University has collaborated with, and received funding from, Rolls Royce; they sponsor research projects aimed at improving the understanding of their products, including analysis and research relating to the performance of their components. Our partnership with Rolls-Royce is described on the University’s website, and gives a general indication of the type of work Rolls-Royce engage in as an example (including projects focusing on heat management, fuel efficiency, and solid mechanics).
However, we will not disclose the value of this funding/collaboration, or any other details, including project titles, as we consider this information to be exempt from disclosure under section 43(2) of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Section 43(2) provides that information is exempt where its disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of any person. Based on the representations made to us, the University is satisfied that disclosure would be likely to prejudice the commercial interests of Rolls Royce. Disclosure of the requested information could identify the specific work Rolls-Royce has asked the University of Oxford to carry out and provide a real and valuable insight into Rolls-Royce’s future strategic plans. Additionally, the separate areas of research information may provide an indication of the relative importance that Rolls-Royce attributes to different technologies and therefore of Rolls-Royce’s technology strategy. This could undermine Rolls-Royce’s competitiveness and damage its reputation amongst third parties who invest or participate in Rolls-Royce’s
research projects. The company has multiple research partners, located in a variety of countries. The amount of funding provided for each of these research partnerships is subject to a high degree of negotiation, and confidential. To disclose the amount provided for the sponsorship and the full project titles would be likely to weaken the company’s position in negotiating the amount of funding it provides to other partners for similar projects.
The University also considers that disclosure would be likely to prejudice its own commercial interests. The disclosure of financial terms, including the value of funding, would be likely to harm the ability of the University to participate competitively in commercial activities in partnership with private companies. Companies would be less willing to enter into agreements with the University if they believed that commercially sensitive information would be disclosed under the FOIA.
The University recognises that there is some public interest in disclosure of the information. Generally, there is an interest in openness and transparency in the conduct of the University’s affairs. More specifically, there is an interest in understanding the University’s relationship with private research funders and the projects they undertake together. However, in respect of the amount of funding provided by Rolls Royce, and further information in relation to the research projects, the University considers that this public interest is outweighed by the following public interest arguments in favour of maintaining the exemption:
There is an inherent public interest in ensuring that the University is able to conduct negotiations on the commercialisation of its research without its negotiating position being compromised through disclosure of information that the funder considers to be commercially sensitive. The University’s high standards of research benefit the UK’s economy; and enhance the UK’s international standing and reputation e.g. by attracting students and researchers from overseas to work at the University. The maintenance of these standards would be jeopardized if the University was less able to conduct confidential discussions with private companies on the joint development of that research.
There is a public interest in the University being able to continue its world-class research, particularly at a time when there is severe pressure on funding for higher education institutions across the UK. Funds raised from private sources are used to support the University’s teaching, research and related activities, including the provision of bursaries for poorer students and activities to widen access. The University’s high standards of teaching and research are valuable and important in their own right. They also benefit the UK’s economy; and enhance the UK’s international standing and reputation e.g. by attracting students and researchers from overseas to work at the University. The maintenance of these standards would be jeopardized if the University was less able to attract private funds, and this would not be in the public interest.
In addition, future collaborators may be reluctant to partner with the University if they conclude that commercially sensitive information associated with such future transactions is likely to be disclosed under FOIA. It would also place the University at a disadvantage compared to private research bodies that are not subject to FOIA.
Section 41 – Information provided in confidence
We also consider that section 41 applies to the information requested in relation to Rolls-Royce. The information about Rolls-Royce’s collaboration with the University is something that is determined by, and is confidential to, Rolls-Royce, rather than something that is the result of a mutual agreement between Rolls-Royce and the University of Oxford. As the requested information was provided to the University by a third party, it therefore falls within the scope of section 41(1)(a).
As regards section 41(1)(b), the requested information relates to Rolls-Royce’s projects with the University. Despite some headline information available on our website at the webpage linked to above, the funding information and exact project titles requested is not information readily available or in the public domain or of a trivial nature; it therefore has the necessary quality of confidence. In addition, all items of information were conveyed in circumstances that implied a duty of confidence. Should the University disclose the information
under FOIA (and therefore to the world at large), it would breach its duty of confidentiality to the third parties concerned, as Rolls-Royce advised when we consulted them on our response to this request.
The exemption in section 41 is an absolute exemption; it is not subject to the public interest test provided for in section 2(2)(b) of the FOIA. However, under the common law, a duty of confidentiality can be overridden if there is a sufficiently strong public interest in the disclosure of the information concerned. This public interest test is the reverse of that normally applied under FOIA; it assumes that the information should be withheld unless the public interest in disclosure outweighs the public interest in maintaining the duty of confidence.
The withheld information relates to funding amounts, full project titles, and collaborators with the University and Rolls-Royce. As some headline information has been released, and Rolls-Royce consider that any unpermitted disclosure of the requested information would be an actionable breach of confidence, we consider that in this particular case, there are no public interest considerations sufficient to override the inherent public interest in maintaining the duty of confidence.
INTERNAL REVIEW
If you are dissatisfied with this reply, you may ask the University to review it by e-mailing [email protected]. A request for internal review should be submitted no later than 40 working days from the date of this letter.
THE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER
If, after the internal review, you are still dissatisfied, you have the right under FOIA to apply to the Information Commissioner for a decision as to whether your request has been dealt with in accordance with the FOIA. You can do this online using the Information Commissioner’s complaints portal.
/----------------------
Clarification Requested:
To ensure we provide the correct information, I would be grateful if you could clarify the following:
- The categories of information you are requesting
- the date range the request should cover;
- whether you are seeking active arrangements only;
If we do not receive a response within two months, we shall regard the request as closed.
/----------------------
Clarification Requested 2:
Thank you for your email. We believe we understand the records the scope should cover, but are still not fully clear on the specific scope. For instance, we may be able to return the names of any projects that fall under these categories and timescales, if they are held, if that is what you are looking to obtain?
Thank you also for clarifying the timeframe.
/----------------------
Follow-up Response:
Thank you for providing this. We will liaise with our data sources to return any data that can be disclosed.