Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Please note that the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
For this request, this is limited to:
- BAE Systems
- Babcock
- QinetiQ
- Rolls-Royce
- Serco
- Cobham
- Raytheon (RTX)
- Airbus
- General Dynamics
- Leonardo MW
- Lockheed Martin
- Thales
- MBDA
- Elbit Systems
- Northrop Grumman
- L3 Harris Technologies
- General Electric
- AVIC
- GKN Aerospace
- Boeing
- Ministry of Defence (MoD)
- Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (DSTL)
- Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
In the request below, the phrase ‘academic partnership’ is related to any partnership within or between universities to collaboratively facilitate the delivery of learning and other strategic opportunities.
This includes the following activities:
- Opportunity advertisements (jobs, graduate schemes, apprenticeships, other opportunities)
- Careers fairs appearances/attendance
- Graduate schemes including studentships
- Apprenticeships including degree apprenticeships
- Sponsorships (events, training, etc.)
- Academic scholarships
- Consultancy fees (paid to the university or paid by the university)
Please may you provide the information broken down by:
1) Please may you provide information on any partnership or funding for ‘academic partnerships’ from ‘arms companies’ from 01 August 2024 to 31 July 2026, broken down by:
- i. The title and descriptions of the purpose of the partnership and academic department(s) involved
- ii. The partners and source of funding (to be included, an arms company can be either a partner or funder of the partnership)
- iii. Academic years, including the start and end date (DD-MM-YY) of the partnership or funding.
- iv. Total amount in GBP provided for each partnership
- v. Other participating UK universities and the nature of their involvement (partner, collaborator, funder).
2) Name of the department or school where the information is located, or if no relevant records are found, where the information would be located.
- a. If the information requested in Question 1 is (would be) located centrally, for example, within the Careers or Student Futures department, please identify the department, faculty, research unit, administrative office, or other part of the university that stores or manages the relevant information for each category listed.
- b. If any part of the information requested in Question 1 is not located centrally, please specify which parts are not held centrally and identify the department, faculty, research unit, administrative office, or other part of the university that stores, manages, or is otherwise most likely to have the relevant information. For example, information related to apprenticeships is held by individual schools or subject departments.
Thank you kindly,
Houcine Doukani
/----------------------
Follow-up Request:
Dear Officer,
I thank you for taking the time to consider my request. I am writing to formally request an internal review be conducted into the decision made to withhold the information requested in this request (ref FOIA/26/171) under s31 - Law Enforcement.
I believe that s31 was incorrectly applied, as from my understanding, it does not impede Prevention and Detection of Crime as defined by the ICO - Please see ICO guidance on applicable circumstance for the use of s31 FOIA:
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/foi/freedom-of-information-and-environmental-information-regulations/section-31-law-enforcement/sections-31-1-a-f-criminal-and-civil-law/
- Section 31(1)(a) - Prevention and Detection of Crime: Protects tactical information, such as police patrolling schedules, internal security codes, or technical IT vulnerabilities that could be exploited by criminals.
- Section 31(1)(b) - Apprehension and Prosecution of Offenders: Protects investigative details that could tip off individuals wanted by the police or compromise evidentiary techniques used by prosecutors.
- Section 31(1)(c) - Administration of Justice: Protects information that could disrupt judicial proceedings, compromise an individual's right to a fair trial, or interfere with confidential court operations.
- Section 31(1)(d) - Assessment or Collection of Tax or Duty: Protects operational frameworks used by tax authorities to catch tax evaders, trace smuggling routes, or close tax avoidance loopholes.
- Section 31(1)(e) - Operation of Immigration Controls: Protects sensitive border intelligence, surveillance methods, and logistics surrounding deportation enforcement.
- Section 31(1)(f) - Maintenance of Security and Good Order in Prisons: Protects operational layouts, CCTV blind spots, or architectural blueprints of prisons, secure hospitals, and detention facilities.
- Section 31(1)(g) - Regulatory Functions: Protects the exercise of public authority duties related to the purposes defined in Section 31(2). This shields active investigations into health and safety compliance, charity mismanagement, professional incompetence (e.g., medical or financial regulators), and the unfitness of company directors.
- Section 31(1)(h) - Civil Proceedings: Protects civil law proceedings brought by or on behalf of a public authority that arise from investigations conducted under subsection 2.
- Section 31(1)(i) - Scottish Fatal Accident Inquiries: Protects inquiries regarding sudden or fatal deaths in Scotland arising out of investigations under subsection 2.
- Section 31(3) - Refusal to Confirm or Deny: Formally removes the duty to confirm or deny whether information exists, if simply answering "yes" or "no" would compromise any of the law enforcement tasks listed in subsection 1.
Please find below my reasoning for each of the University's arguments against disclosure:
- Disclosure could increase the risk of criminal activity, including vandalism, trespass, harassment or disruption directed at the University, its staff, students or partners.
Speculation as to the nature of the public response to the contents of the information disclosed, from my understanding, does fall under any of the subsections defined above
- Releasing details of partnerships could expose sensitive information about activities connected to strategically significant sectors.
If the term 'strategically significant sectors' refers to those activities that are strategically significant to the University and or the partner/funder company, then, from my understanding, Section 31 does not apply.
- There is a strong public interest in protecting the safety and security of the University's people, property and operations.
speculation into public's response to the contents of the information disclosed, does not fall under Section 31.
- Disclosure under FOIA is to the world at large, and the University cannot control how the information may be used.
This is true for all information disclosed under FOIA- The burden is placed on the University to justify the withholding of information in-line exemptions set out in the FOIA. At the very least, this is a neutral point and can also be considered as a point favouring disclosure do the requirement for transparency.
- In the Northern Ireland context, defence-related partnerships can attract significant public controversy and scrutiny, potentially creating security, safety or reputational risks for staff, students and partner organisations.
Defence-related partnerships may also elicit the complete opposite response. It is not the part of the university to withhold information because the public could potentially hold a negative or positive view of the information, under S31. Other points in this argument (security, safety or reputational risks for staff, students and partner organisations) are a repetition of the first and second argument against disclosure)
Thanks again for taking the time to consider and process my response. If you have any further questions about this request, please feel free to detail your query in a reply to this email. I look forward to hearing from you soon.
Kind Regards,
Houcine Doukani
Response Refusal Reason
The university confirmed it holds the information but withheld all of it under section 31(1)(a) (prevention or detection of crime). It argued that disclosure would be likely to increase the risk of criminal activity such as criminal damage, trespass or harassment directed at the university, its staff, students or partners, citing the Northern Ireland context and past direct-action campaigns, and that the public interest favoured withholding. dED requested an internal review on 09/09/2026; the review upheld the refusal on 18/09/2026, adding that the combined dataset could be used to map and target defence-related activities (the 'mosaic effect').
Response Text
Dear Houcine
We acknowledge receipt of your recent request under the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (ref FOIA/26/171). Your request is receiving attention and we hope to have a response to you by 14/9/2026.
We will keep you updated in respect of the status of your request.
Regards
FOI Team
/----------------------
Follow-up Response:
Dear Houcine
RESPONSE FOIA/26/171
Further to your request, in which you have requested information relating to academic partnerships with SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
The university's restatement of the request is not repeated here.
Our Obligations
The University is handling your request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. When handling requests for information, the University's obligations include:
- Confirming or denying whether it holds information of the description specified in the request; and
- Communication the information requested to the applicant. You should note that this is effectively a decision that the information can be released into the public domain and not simply to the specific applicant.
Under the Act, the University is required to release any information that it holds to you unless an exemption applies.
Our Response
Further to your request, the University's response is as follows:
The University can confirm that it holds the information you have requested. This information is withheld under Section 31 of the FOIA - law enforcement. This is to prevent the disclosure of information which could prejudice the prevention or detection of crime.
After careful consideration, the University has concluded that to disclosure the requested information, that it would be likely to prejudice the University's security. The information is withheld under Section 31(1) of the FOIA, which states that information is exempt if "its disclosure under this Act would, or would be likely to prejudice (a) the prevention or detection of crime".
Public Interest Test
In line with the terms of this exemption in the Freedom of Information Act, we have also considered whether it would be in the public interest for us to provide you with the information, despite the exemption being applicable.
Arguments for disclosure
- Openness and transparency
- Public interest in how the University spends its money.
- Public interest in how the University makes its decisions.
Arguments against disclosure
- Disclosure could increase the risk of criminal activity, including vandalism, trespass, harassment or disruption directed at the University, its staff, students or partners.
- Releasing details of partnerships could expose sensitive information about activities connected to strategically significant sectors.
- There is a strong public interest in protecting the safety and security of the University's people, property and operations.
- Disclosure under FOIA is to the world at large, and the University cannot control how the information may be used.
- In the Northern Ireland context, defence-related partnerships can attract significant public controversy and scrutiny, potentially creating security, safety or reputational risks for staff, students and partner organisations.
Balancing test
The University recognises the public interest in transparency regarding its partnerships and funding arrangements. However, in this case, the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the stronger public interest in protecting the University's security and reducing the risk of crime. The balance of the public interest therefore favours maintaining the exemption under Section 31(1)(a) of the FOIA
Further information on this exemption is available on the ICO website: law-enforcement-foi-section-31.pdf (ico.org.uk).
If you are not satisfied with how the University has dealt with your request, you may raise the matter under the University's internal review process for FOI requests. Please submit written details of your appeal to [the University Secretary], University of Ulster, Coleraine BT52 1SA, email at [email protected]. The University will normally undertake to issue a decision on an appeal within 20 working days of receipt.
If you do not wish to submit an appeal to the University in relation to your request or if you are unhappy with the outcome of an appeal, you may apply to the Office of the Information Commissioner. Full particulars of the FOI Act including the Information Commissioner's address may be found at www.ico.org.uk.
Data Protection & Information Compliance Unit
/----------------------
Follow-up Response 2:
Dear Houcine Doukani
On behalf of Ulster University, I acknowledge receipt of your appeal of the University's FOI response, ref: FOIA/26/171.
Your appeal is under consideration, and a response will be issued in due course.
Yours sincerely
Personal Assistant to the University Secretary
/----------------------
Follow-up Response 3:
Dear Houcine Doukani
RESPONSE: APPEAL FOIA/26/171
I have had the opportunity to review your request for an appeal under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) 2000, in which you requested information relating to University partnerships, or funding for academic partnerships, from 'arms companies' from 1 August 2024 to 31 July 2026. In your request you defined 'arms companies' as being those within SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News top 100 lists.
In response to your request, the FOI Team applied section 31(1)(a) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Section 31(1)(a) provides an exemption from disclosure where information would, or would be likely to, prejudice the prevention or detection of crime.
I acknowledge, as noted in your request for Internal Review, that Section 31 cannot be engaged solely because information may be controversial or attract criticism. It is important to note that the FOI Team apply an exemption to information where disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the prevention or detection of crime.
The information requested seeks detailed information concerning arms companies' partnerships, including any potential funding arrangements, collaboration and participating academic departments. The FOI Team considered that disclosure would be likely to create a real and significant risk of facilitating criminal activity directed towards University campuses, staff, researchers, and partner organisations.
The criminal activity identified and considered would include, but not be limited to, criminal damage, trespass, harassment, intimidation of staff or offences directed at disrupting the lawful activities of the University. The concern is not based solely on the possibility that members of the public may disagree with defence-related activity. Rather, this is considered on the basis of a history of direct-action campaigns, which can involve criminal activity, against organisations perceived to be connected with the defence sector.
The University's assessment has also considered the local context. While each request must be assessed on its own merits, the University notes that Northern Ireland has experienced incidents in which organisations associated with defence-related activity have been subjected to direct action involving unlawful conduct. The University is not suggesting that all opposition to defence-sector activity is unlawful, nor that such conduct would necessarily occur in this case. However, such incidents demonstrate that the risk identified is not purely theoretical and support the University's view that there is a real and significant possibility of unlawful activity being directed towards organisations perceived to be associated with the defence sector.
The University also considered that higher education institutions within the UK have, on occasion, been the focus of direct-action campaigns, protests and disruption relating to research activities, external partnerships and recruitment activity associated with the defence sector. In some instances, such activity has resulted in heightened security measures, disruption to events, or the withdrawal of participating organisations. The requested information would provide a level of detail that could assist those seeking to identify and focus attention on specific University activities.
The University's position is not that disclosure would merely attract criticism or lawful protest. Rather, the concern is that disclosure under FOIA would place into the public domain a consolidated dataset identifying defence-related partnerships, participating academic areas, funding arrangements, and timescales. This would materially assist any individual or group seeking to identify, map and target University activities associated with the defence sector. In the University's view, there is a clear causal connection between the disclosure of the requested information and an increased risk of criminal conduct directed towards University premises, personnel, or partners.
The University notes that the First-tier Tribunal has recognised that section 31(1)(a) may be engaged where disclosure would be likely to facilitate harassment, intimidation or other criminal conduct directed towards organisations or individuals associated with activities that have attracted opposition from activist groups. In Case No. UKFTT-00451-(GRC), the Tribunal accepted that evidence of previous harassment and intimidation was relevant when assessing whether the prejudice test was met and concluded that disclosure could prejudice the prevention of crime even where no active criminal investigation was underway.
The Tribunal further recognised that information which may appear relatively innocuous when viewed in isolation can nevertheless contribute to a risk of unlawful activity when combined with information already available in the public domain. The University considers these principles relevant in the present case, given the detailed nature of the information requested and the potential for it to be used, either alone or in conjunction with other publicly available information, to identify and target defence-related activities, departments, locations or partners associated with the University.
In addition to this, the ICO recognises in How should we apply the prejudice test? | ICO for Section 31, that information which appears benign when considered individually may become sensitive when combined with other publicly available information, commonly referred to as the "mosaic effect".
Your initial request was seeking detailed information regarding the identities of potential industry partners, participating departments, funding values, and project timescales. Disclosure would assist interested parties in mapping the University's defence-related activities and identifying specific sites, departments, researchers or programmes which may become the focus of protest or direct-action campaigns. The risk identified arises not only from any single data item but from the aggregation of the requested information.
As section 31(1) is a qualified exemption, I have reconsidered the Public Interest Test as part of this Internal Review. For ease of reference, the additional argument I have considered has been included in italics below.
Arguments for disclosure
- Openness and transparency
- Public interest in how the University spends its money.
- Public interest in how the University makes its decisions.
- Contribute to public debate regarding relationships between universities and defence-sector organisations.
- Improve public understanding of research activity and funding.
Arguments against disclosure
- Disclosure could increase the risk of criminal activity, including vandalism, trespass, harassment, or disruption directed at the University, its staff, students, or partners.
- Releasing details of partnerships could expose sensitive information about activities connected to strategically significant sectors.
- There is a strong public interest in protecting the safety and security of the University's people, property, and operations.
- Disclosure under FOIA is to the world at large, and the University cannot control how the information may be used.
- In the Northern Ireland context, defence-related partnerships may attract heightened attention from individuals or groups opposed to such activities, increasing the risk of attempts to identify, target or disrupt those activities.
- protecting University premises from risks of criminal damage or unlawful disruption.
- protecting partner organisations from being targeted through information disclosed by the University.
- avoiding facilitating criminal activity through the release of detailed location and partnership information.
- protecting the University's ability to carry on its lawful teaching and research activities without disruption.
The University recognises the significant public interest in transparency concerning research funding and external partnerships, and I have given substantial weight to those considerations. However, disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act is effectively disclosure to the world at large.
Having carefully considered the nature and level of detail of the information requested, I consider that there is a stronger public interest in avoiding the creation of a real and significant risk that the information could be used to facilitate criminal conduct, disrupt the lawful activities of the University, or contribute to the targeting of University premises, staff, students or partner organisations. In the circumstances of this case, those factors outweigh the public interest in disclosure.
If you are unhappy with the outcome of this appeal, you may apply to the Office of the Information Commissioner. Full particulars of the FOI Act including the Information Commissioner's address may be found at www.ico.org.uk.
Yours sincerely
University Secretary Ulster University