Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
In the below request the phrase the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
BAE
Babcock
QinetiQ
Rolls-Royce
Serco
Cobham
Raytheon
AirbusGeneral Dynamics
Leonardo MW
Lockheed Martin
Thales
MBDA
Elbit Systems
Caterpillar
Ministry Of Defence
DSTL
Atomic Weapons establishment
GKN
Boeing
‘Academic partnership’ refers to ‘arms trade companies’ involvement of any of the following:
1. Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances
2. Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships
-
Public donations - sponsored buildings/libraries etc
-
Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research
5. Dual employment of staff/management or lecturers
Please may I request any information or appearance of arms trade companies in the aforementioned capacities in the past five years.
When referring to option 1., 2., or 3., or 4., please may you provide the value:
• Of the donation
• Of the studentship
• Of Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/careers fair appearances
• Of the funding for the department/research centres
When referring to option 3, 4. Or 5., please may you provide the:
• Name of the relevant university department or programme if applicable
• Name of building if applicable
• Name of the dual employed staff member if applicable
Many thanks
Response Refusal Reason
They rejected the request due to section 12 of the Act, which states the research time would exceed 18 hours of staff work. However, they amalgamated 3 responses, without any indication they would do so, or give me an option for me to only submit one. After requesting an internal review, they still rejected the request.
Response Text
Your request has been dealt with under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (“the Act”).
The University has taken account of the legislation and guidance issued by the Information Commissioner’s Office and considered your requests together.
Having done so, we have determined that, whilst the University may hold some of the information that you have requested, the cost of resources required to retrieve and prepare the information would exceed the appropriate limit under section 12 of the Act. The limit we are required to commit is £450, which is equivalent to 18 hours of staff time charged at £25 per hour. Therefore, on this occasion the University is unable to comply with your requests, which are refused in accordance with section 12(1) of the Act.
You can find out more about the relevant section of the Act, and some guidance points which the University has considered when applying the Act in this response, in the form of a Guidance Note attached to this letter.
In considering the costs, the University has followed the guidance issued by the Information Commissioner’s Office in relation to aggregation of requests. We have considered your requests together when assessing whether the appropriate limit is likely to be exceeded. The
ICO’s guidance states that the public authority “can include the costs of complying with two or more requests if the conditions laid out in regulation 5 of the Fees Regulations can be satisfied”.
“Those conditions require the requests to be:
• made by one person, or by different persons who appear to the public authority to be acting in concert or in pursuance of a campaign;
• made for the same or similar information; and
• received by the public authority within any period of 60 consecutive working days.”
<hr />To whom it may concern,
I just received your response, but would like to request a review. I am aware of the exemption of response due to costs exceeding £450, but at no point did you tell me you would consider all three requests I sent as one. If you did, I would have only submitted one, and waited the appropriate 60 days to submit another, so that I could get a response.
In the response, you said I must contact an Alexandra Elliot for this review, but no contact details were given. Please may I be pointed in the right direction?
Many thanks,
Millie
<hr />Internal review
I have reviewed the University’s response to your FOI request and your email of 27 April 2023 and I am satisfied that the University responded appropriately and the time exemption was correctly applied.
I have carefully considered the guidance published by the Information Commissioner’s Office in relation to the time exemption - available here: https://ico.org.uk/media/for-organisations/documents/1199/costs_of_compliance_exceeds_appropriate_limit.pdf) – and, in particular, the guidance in relation to aggregation of requests on page 12 onwards. I consider that the guidance was correctly applied.
S.16 of the Act does require a public authority “to provide advice and assistance, so far as it would be reasonable to expect the authority to do so” and to conform with any Code of Practice made under S.45 of the Act.
Where a public authority does not comply with a request because it would exceed the appropriate time limit, the Code of Practice does state that the public authority “…should consider providing an indication of what, if any, information could be provided within the cost ceiling. The authority should also consider advising the applicant that by reforming or re-focussing their request, information may be able to be supplied for a lower, or no, fee”. That advice and guidance was provided in the University’s response of 25 April 2023.
However, the Code does not require the University to pre-emptively advise a requestor that their requests may be aggregated or that the time exemption may be applied, and I do not consider that it would be reasonable to expect the University to do so.
Therefore, I am satisfied that the University responded appropriately to your three FOI requests. However, if you remain dissatisfied, you have the right of appeal to the Information Commissioner's Office. Details can be found here: https://ico.org.uk/make-a-complaint/.
Yours sincerely,
The University considers that the conditions have been met in this case. You have submitted three separate requests between 27 March 2023 and 11 April 2023 and the requests to relate to the same or similar information. We note that the University’s relationship and financial arrangements with ‘arms trade companies’ is the overarching theme / common thread running through the requests.
Additional information has been provided below in relation to the time / costs involved in responding to your requests and you can contact us for further advice.
From the information below you will also note that some of your individual requests, in themselves, would not be feasible within the time limit. This is because it would take more than 18 hours to determine whether the University holds the requested information, and to then find, retrieve and extract the information.