Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
I am writing to request information on the research and financial relationships the university holds in the following companies: BAE Systems, Lockheed Martin, QinetiQ, Rolls-Royce, GKN, Cobham, Elbit Systems, Leonardo, L3 Technologies, Northrop Grumman, Raytheon, Thales, Boeing, General Dynamics, Airbus, United Technologies, Babcock International, Serco, Meggitt, AirTanker, Chemring and Ultra Electronics and any other defence sector companies.
Additionally, I am writing to request information on the contracts the university holds with the Ministry of Defence and equivalent bodies and armed forces of other countries.
Please include the following information:
1) For each of the above companies/bodies please list all the projects, industrial consultancy and industrial research that the university has received funding for over the past four academic years, 2017-2018, 2018-2019, 2019-2020, and 2020-2021. Details should be broken down by each university department, showing the company or government body who have provided funding, the start and end date of each contract, title of the project/research, and total funding of each project/research year-by-year for the past four academic years. Lastly, please list all external organisations and bodies that are also participants in the projects/research identified.
2) Does the university have, or is it working towards, an ethical research policy that excludes, or could exclude, the companies listed above?
Response Refusal Reason
S43 (2) Commercial Interests
Section 43(2) exempts information whose disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of any legal person (an individual, a company, the public authority itself or any other legal entity).
In this case, Rolls-Royce argue that:
‘such information provides an indication of the relative importance that Rolls-Royce attributes to different technologies and therefore of Rolls-Royce’s technology strategy.’
‘The disclosure of any information that provide an insight into Rolls-Royce’s technology strategy could provide Rolls-Royce’s competitors with an advantage and therefore prejudice Rolls-Royce’s interests.’
We consider the exemption applies in this case as Rolls-Royce have made it clear that to release it would cause them harm and be advantageous to their competitors; the information is not already in the public domain; and it could not be easily discovered by other means.
We have considered the public interest in disclosure, that being the accountability and transparency of decisions made and the spending of public money but feel in this case that the commercial interests of the company outweigh that of the public interest in disclosure.
We believe that release of this information would disadvantage Rolls-Royce in relation to their competitors. As there is a public interest in ensuring that companies can compete fairly, it is our decision that this information should not be disclosed. We feel this is a suitable compromise given that public accountability has been met by the provision of the details of each individual project and overall spend.
Response Text
Please accept our apologies for the significant delay in response. The University has now considered your request and our response can be found below:
Please find the table below containing the information held in response to question 1 of your request.
| Funder | Department | Title | Start Date | End Date | 2020/21 | 2019/20 | 2018/19 | 2017/18 | Project type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAE Systems | |||||||||
| School of Engineering | Aircraft Control System Design Optimisation | 01/08/2020 | 30/04/2021 | 119,976.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| School of Engineering | Aircraft Control System | 01/07/2021 | 31/03/2022 | - 343,913.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Novel 3D woven Composites | 07/12/2020 | 28/02/2021 | £ 21,062.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| School of Natural Sciences | BAE Systems Accelerator | 01/08/2021 | 31/12/2025 | £ 67,981.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| Rolls-Royce | |||||||||
| School of Engineering | SoW EIM4010 Support to provide an engine soot incandescence non-intrusive imaging system at INTA | 20/12/2018 | 19/06/2019 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Engineering | Electronic Systems in Ionising Radiation Environments - Phase 1: Development of Design Guidance and Qualification Process | 20/08/2018 | 19/02/2019 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Engineering | Reactor Physics and Engineering Investigation of Molten Salt Reactors | 30/09/2018 | 29/09/2020 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Slow strain rate tensile testing and characterisation of stainless steel | 16/06/2018 | 15/09/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Isothermal autoclave testing and characterisation of ZIRCALOY-4 | 01/03/2018 | 30/06/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Engineering | Non-intrusive engine exhaust laser induced incandescence system | 01/11/2017 | 01/08/2019 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | A multi-mineral test dust to quantify degradation mechanisms in gas turbine engines by foreign particulate matter (sand and dusts): whole engine test | 16/10/2017 | 15/05/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Study of ceramic powders for manufacture of EBCs and Development of steam testing rig | 27/11/2017 | 26/05/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Specification for Testing of Lowk EB-PVD TBC Systems | 01/12/2017 | 28/02/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Research and development activities at University of Manchester Materials Department in support of CMC coating Technology -Literature reviews and Characterisation Support on Tested Coatings | 01/12/2017 | 30/11/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Research and development activities at University of Manchester Materials Department in support of CEMTEC Work Package 3. | 01/03/2018 | 28/02/2021 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | The influence of microstructure on the effect constraint has on fracture toughness | 01/10/2017 | 31/08/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Irradiation Damage, Senior Fellow | 25/12/2017 | 24/12/2021 | Research Funding | |||||
| School of Natural Sciences | High Resolution Digital Image Correlation for measurement of the Ductile-Brittle Transition | 01/10/2017 | 31/08/2018 | Research Funding | |||||
| TOTAL FUNDING | £402,771.00 | £526,755.00 | £714,422.00 | £584,929.00 | |||||
| Thales | |||||||||
| School of Natural Sciences | Graphene photonic pressure sensors | 01/10/2015 | 31/03/2019 | £ 112,815.00 | £ 112,815.00 | Research Funding | |||
| School of Natural Sciences | Smarthub 2 | 13/02/2017 | 12/09/2020 | £ 48,245.67 | £ 48,245.67 | £ 48,245.67 | Research Funding | ||
| Boeing | |||||||||
| School of Engineering | Aerospace Electrical Creepage Phenomena | 01/07/2019 | 31/12/2020 | £ 41,172.30 | Research Funding | ||||
| School of Engineering | Creepage Distance Testing For Aerospace | 01/11/2018 | 31/12/2018 | £ 33,862.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| Airbus | |||||||||
| Department of Materials | Cr(VI)-free primer performance | 01/10/2019 | 30/09/2021 | £94,200.00 | £94,200.00 | £94,200.00 | Research Funding | ||
| Department of Materials | 7xxx (H)EAC Programme - Characterization | 07/04/2018 | 31/01/2022 | £79,840.40 | £79,840.40 | £79,840.40 | £79,840.40 | Research Funding | |
| Graphene Engineering Innovation Centre | Tier 2 Membership | 02/01/2019 | 01/01/2020 | £13,333.33 | £13,333.33 | £13,333.33 | Research Funding | ||
| Department of Materials | 7xxx (H)EAC Programme - Characterization | 07/04/2018 | 31/07/2021 | £107,190.50 | £107,190.50 | £107,190.50 | £107,190.50 | Research Funding | |
| Department of Materials | I-Break | 01/04/2021 | 01/06/2025 | £1,340,000.00 | Research Funding | ||||
| Department of Materials | New Wing | 01/04/2021 | 01/09/2025 | £1,133,333.33 | Research Funding |
We have consulted with all organisations involved, and have received representation back from Rolls-Royce, who have no objections to release of the information requested, with the exception of funding broken down at project level.
Having considered their argument and the public interest test, we are in agreement with the representation made. We are therefore relying upon the exemption within Section 43(2) of the Act, concerning Commercial Interests, to refuse the breakdown of funding at project level for Rolls-Royce. We have however, provided the total funding amount.
In terms of question 2 in which you ask:
2) Does the university have, or is it working towards, an ethical research policy that excludes, or could exclude, the companies listed above?
Our research governance, ethics and integrity information is all publicly available - Research governance, ethics and integrity at The University of Manchester. As detailed in our Policy for Socially Responsible Investment, we do not invest in coal, oil and gas, and we have no holdings in companies producing tobacco, controversial weapons and those with the lowest environmental, social and governance rating.
I hope you find the information provided above and attached of use.