Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
I sent an FOI request on the 27th of March, that was rejected under the exemption of requests. You gave me advice on how to proceed so that the request would not be rejected for the same reasoning, which was greatly appreciated. The request therefore is:
In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Mitsubishi heavy industries
In the below request, the phrase ‘research project' related to, but not limited to:
Any academic research collaborations that involve any staff members or any member of the active student body with companies or institutions who have stakes in the defence industry and arms trade companies.
Please may you provide A list of research projects funded by any of the listed companies/organisations in the last two years, 2021/22 and 2022/23 to date providing the following details:
- Title of research project;
- University department involved;
-
Total amount of research project funding received by the University of St Andrews each year;
-
Project start and end dates.
Many thanks,
Millie
Response Refusal Reason
43(2) Commercial interests
Response Text
This response is being made under both the FOISA and the Environmental Information (Scotland) Act 2004 (EIRs).
A search has been carried out of our financial records against the named funders to locate contracted research projects where funding was received from these sponsors in the last two financial years. For your information, the University’s financial year runs from 1 August to 31 July. The information located and retrieved from the records that we hold as part of this exercise is being provided as detailed in the attached Appendix A.
The information requested is being released to you in full except for:
- • The exact title of the project sponsored by Leonardo UK Ltd as held in our records is being withheld as detailed below. Instead, a summarised description is provided which gives a broad understanding of the research subject area.
The research project sponsored by Leonardo UK Ltd falls under the definition of environmental information as set out in the EIRs i.e. factors, measures and activities, affecting or likely to affect the state of the elements [Regulations 2(1)(a), (b) and (c) of the EIRs].
Disclosure of information in relation to this project is therefore being managed under the EIRs rather than the FOISA. The EIRs provide a separate statutory right of access to environmental information and your rights will not therefore be diminished as a result of the University responding solely in line with those provisions. As a formality and in order to meet the technical requirements of the FOISA, section 39(2) of the FOISA is being applied in this respect.
The full title of this research project is being withheld under regulation 10(5)(e) of the EIRs as disclosure of this information is likely to prejudice substantially the confidentiality of commercial information where such confidentiality is provided for by law to protect a legitimate economic interest.
Leonardo UK is a private company that carries out commercial activities. The withheld information is not publicly available and it is believed that disclosure would have a detrimental impact on the company’s commercial interests.
There is an agreement in place in relation to the research project which is subject to explicit confidentiality provisions. Leonardo UK Ltd are of the view that disclosure of the full project title reveals information that they consider to be commercially sensitive. Disclosure of the withheld level of detail would give competitors an insight into the capability of Leonardo UK Ltd which would be detrimental to the company’s commercial interests, harming their ability to operate effectively, significantly weakening their position in a highly competitive environment.
On reaching this conclusion, the University has been guided by Decision 042/2017 Mr Gary Barwood and the Scottish Futures Trust which accepted that information subject to contractual agreements between public authorities and third parties relates directly to their commercial interests.
The Commissioner was also satisfied in this case that substantial prejudice to the commercial interests of an existing supplier would be caused through the disclosure of information that provides competing third parties with intelligence that can be used to their advantage.
Public Interest
When applying the regulation 10(5)(e), EIR exception, the University must consider where the public interest lies i.e. whether continued application of the exemption to with-hold the information outweighs disclosure.
There is a strong public interest in private companies being able to trade fairly and provide a viable business in a competitive market. It would not be in the public interest for commercial companies to be treated unfairly, placing them at a disadvantage as a result of having a contractual agreement with a public body. It is a matter of significant public interest that commercial trading companies are able to protect and further their own commercial interests, generating employment opportunities which in turn, is beneficial to the economy and public at large.
The University is of the view that the level of information being made available as part of this response sufficiently addresses the public interest in transparency and accountability of public bodies i.e. details have been disclosed of the area of research being undertaken by the University and how this is being funded. On balance, the public interest has been found to lie in the information being withheld and the regulation 10(5)(e), EIR exception being applied. Information Assurance and Governance 01334 462776 [email protected] The University of St Andrews is a charity registered in Scotland, No: SC013532
The conclusion reached by the University is in line with that of the Scottish Information Commissioner in Decision Notice 020/2019: Integrated Aquaculture Rapid Mortality Recovery System which found that the public interest favoured the withholding of information under regulation 10(5)(e) of the EIRs stating that:
“it is in the public interest for those organisations operating within a competitive market to be able to do so, with potential competitors, on a fair and equal footing. This is particularly relevant where the information relates to new products and processes, which may still be subject to further development.”
Your right to seek a review of how your information request was managed
If you are not satisfied with the University’s response and/or our reasoning set-out above, you have the right to request a review of our decision. The timelines in which this right is available are set out in section 20(5)(a) and (b) FOISA and regulation 16 of the EIRs. In broad terms the right to seek a review must be exercised within 40 working days of receiving this response.
Any request for review at this time should be sent by email to [email protected] stating:
- a) your name and address;
- b) details of your original request; and
- c) the reasons why you are dissatisfied with our response.
If you remain dissatisfied with how your request for information has been dealt with following Review, you also have the right to apply to the Scottish Information Commissioner (SIC) for a decision. In the event of an appeal to the SIC, the Commissioner will generally only be able to investigate the matters raised in the request for review.
Details on how to make an appeal online to the SIC can be found on their website: http://www.itspublicknowledge.info/YourRights/Unhappywiththeresponse/AppealingtoCommissioner.aspx .
This concludes the University’s response.
Yours sincerely