See how much your university is linked to the arms trade →

Freedom of Information (FoI) Request

Request Date
13 Jul, 2023
Response Date
26 Jul, 2023
Provision
Fully or partially refused

See the refusal reason.

Military Links
Unknown

Request Text

To whom it may concern,

In the below request the phrase the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:

  1. BAE systems

  2. Babcock

  3. QinetiQ

  4. Rolls-Royce

  5. Serco

  6. Cobham

  7. Raytheon

  8. Airbus

  9. General Dynamics

  10. Leonardo MW

  11. Lockheed Martin

  12. Thales

  13. MBDA

  14. Elbit Systems

  15. Caterpillar

  16. MOD

  17. DSTL

  18. Atomic Weapons establishment

  19. GKN

  20. Boeing

‘Academic partnership’ refers to ‘arms trade companies’ involvement of any of the following:

• Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances

• Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships

• Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research.

• Any consultancy role.

Please may I request any relevant information or appearance of arms trade companies in the aforementioned capacities in the past five years:

  • The name of the arms company involved
  • The financial value of the relationship
  • The name of the relevant university department
  • The name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship

Many Thanks,

Millie

Response Refusal Reason

Refused the request under section 14(2) of the FOI act, which states that requests can be refused if too similar. I requested an internal review, but that was also rejected.

Response Text

Good morning,

I acknowledge the receipt of your request for information dated 13 July 2023.

Section 14(2) of the Freedom of Information Act makes provision for public authorities to refuse a request for information as repeated (provided that the public authority has previously provided the information requested) if:

  • it is made by the same person as a previous request;
  • It is identical or substantially similar to the previous request; and
  • no reasonable interval has elapsed since the previous request.

In our opinion, your previous request made on 21 April 2023 and 17 May 2023 to which the University responded on 17 May (reference FOI 3428) and 14 June 2023 (reference 3448) respectively satisfies all the above criteria. Consequently, under Section 14(2) your request will not be processed further and this email constitutes a refusal notice under Section 17(4) of the Act.

If you are dissatisfied with the handling of your request, you have the right to ask for an internal review. Internal review requests should be submitted within 40 working days from the date of our response to your original request and should be addressed to the University Secretary, University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield HD1 3DH or by email to [email protected].

Please note that all copyright in this response belongs to the University of Huddersfield; you are not permitted to publish, reproduce, copy or otherwise use this response, except as permitted by the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

Further information about the Freedom of Information Act can be obtained from the Information Commissioner’s Office, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 5AF, http://www.ico.org.uk/.

Yours sincerely

Esha Goswami

<hr />

To whom it may concern,

I would like to ask for an internal review for the request I sent on the 13/07/2023. You have refused the request under section 14(2) of the FOI act. However I disagree that the request sent is

  • it is made by the same person as a previous request;
  • It is identical or substantially similar to the previous request; and
  • no reasonable interval has elapsed since the previous request

Whilst the request is about the university involvement with arms companies, like the other 2 requests I sent, It is about very separate information regarding university ties to the arms trade, which is why it was put in a separate request.

I sent one FOI on the 24/04/2023 regarding investments

I sent one FOI on the 17/05/2023 regarding research projects.

The FOI I sent on the 13/07/2023 is about academic partnerships, which is defined in the FOI and has nothing to do with either investments or research projects, but sponsorships/gifts/department funding.

Many thanks and looking forward to your response.

Millie

<hr />

Dear Millie,

Further to your e-mail dated 11 August 2023, requesting an internal review of our response to your request under Freedom of Information Act (the Act) dated 26 July 2023, please find below my response on behalf of the University of Huddersfield (“the University”).

1. Review Process

In conducting this internal review I have carefully reviewed your requests and the University’s responses, which are summarised below:

•             Your Freedom of Information request dated 21 April, 17 May and 13 July 2023 and our responses dated 17 May, 14 June and 26 July respectively.

•             Your e-mail dated 11 August 2023 requesting a review of the University’s handling of your request.

Please note that we have not taken into account your request dated 24 April 2023 (reference FOI 3429) and 17 May 2023 (reference FOI 3447) regarding direct investments, to which the University responded to on 17 May and 14 June 2023.

2. Response

The University’s previous response reference 3498, explained that the information requested was exempt under Section 14 (2) of the Freedom of Information Act because in our opinion, the request was a repeated request. Under Section 14 (2) of the Act, public authorities are able to refuse a request on vexatious or repeated requests grounds provided it is identical, or substantially similar to a previous request submitted by the same individual, unless a reasonable period has elapsed between those requests.

Our response outlined that in view of the history of previous correspondence with yourself, the University was of the opinion that the subject matter of your request was substantially similar to your previous requests and that there was no reasonable interval that elapsed since the previous responses.

3. Outcome of Internal Review

Having undertaken a detailed analysis I can confirm the following:

FOI request date Your request Our response
21 April 2023 (Ref: 3428) Any academic research collaborations that involve any staff members or any member of the active student body with companies or institutions who have stakes in the defence industry and arms trade companies.   You requested to provide all research projects with any connection to arms trade companies in the last five years. Connections to include sources of funding and/or collaborative research partnership on the research project. Information requested were about the title and aim of the projects, companies and departments involved, funding amount and the time scale of these projects. Section 12(1) exemption applied.   Our response explained that the University has a large number of students who actively participate in research projects and collaborates with a large number of external organisations. We provided information and guidance about how we could respond to your request within the time limit.
17 May 2023 (Ref: 3448) Any academic research collaborations that involve any staff members or any member of the active student body with companies or institutions from a list of ten organisations that you provided.   You requested to provide all research projects with any connection to arms trade companies in the past 2 years.  Connections to include sources of funding and/or collaborative research partnership on the research project. Information requested were about the title and aim of the projects, companies and departments involved, funding amount and the time scale of these projects. Information requested was provided subject to relevant sections exempted.
13 July 2023 (Ref: 3498) Academic partnership with arms trade companies in any of the following: Graduate schemes, apprenticeships, careers fair appearances, directly sponsored PhDs, company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research and any consultancy role.   You requested relevant information for the past five years about the names of the arms companies, financial value of the relationship, department involved and the name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship. Section 14(2) exemption applied
  • The ICO guidance on the applying the Section 14(2) of the FOI Act notes that this exemption could be applied if the University has previously provided the same requester with the information in response to an earlier FOI request.

The University’s response to FOI 3448, provided a list of research collaborations that the University have had within the scope of your request. Please note that the University of Huddersfield has a wealth of experience in connecting organisations with our award-winning research and expertise. Academic partnerships with organisations are largely done via research collaborations.

  • In line with the ICO guidance, a request is substantially similar if the wording is different but the scope of the request is the same; or the scope does not differ significantly from that of the previous request.

Having reviewed all your requests, as listed above, I have concluded that your request dated 13 July 2023 is substantially similar to the previous ones as listed above.

  • The ICO guidance on section 14(2) advises that the reasonable interval is largely dependent on how likely it is that any of the information caught within the scope of the request differs or has changed  since previously provided it.

I have noted the dates of our previous response to FOI 3448 (14 June 2023) and your subsequent request dated 13 July 2023 (FOI 3498) and have concluded that no reasonable interval has elapsed.

Having undertaken a detailed analysis, my review has concluded that the University's response to your request is upheld. The University has applied the exemption under Section 14(2) correctly in line with the FOIA.

I would like to highlight that the University has not taken into account the additional two FOI requests that you submitted (references: 3429 and 3447) as we consider these requests were about University’s investment and thereby, significantly different from the ones noted above. Please note that this has not been a factor in the University’s decision to apply the Section 14(2) exemption, nor my decision to uphold the University’s response.

If you have any queries or concerns regarding the handling of the internal review, please do not hesitate to contact me via [email protected]

If you are not satisfied with this response, you have a right of appeal to the Information Commissioner’s Office, Wycliffe House, Water Lane, Wilmslow, Cheshire, SK9 5AF: http://www.ico.org.uk/

Yours sincerely

Alison Jones

Data sources

Source

This is an FoI request submitted by dED staff