See how much your university is linked to the arms trade →

Freedom of Information (FoI) Request

Request Date
29 Sep, 2022
Response Date
24 Nov, 2022
Provision
Fully or partially refused

See the refusal reason.

Military Links
No

Request Text

To whom it may concern,

I’d like to thank you for your previous replies to my requests, they were incredibly detailed and appreciated.

In the annual investment policy that is distributed amongst the City council, it makes clear that "external investment management" is used in a majority of City’s investments, including endowment funds.

Please can you provide:

1) A detailed list of the names of these investment management companies or individuals,

2) the amount that the University gives them to manage and the returns on these investments

3) the types of investments that they manage

4) And if available, a list of the companies/organisations/investments made on behalf of the university by these investors.

Please may the response be categorised in that order, and may this please be for the last five financial years.

Many thanks,

Millie

Response Refusal Reason

City considers the information requested about the management and the returns on City’s investments to be exempt information under section 43(2) of the FOIA 2000, as we consider that disclosure of this information would be likely to prejudice City’s commercial interests.

City considers the information requested about the companies/organisations/investments made on behalf of the University to be exempt information under Section 22 of the FOIA 2000. City intends for the information to be published and accessible online to the public at a future date and, that, in all circumstances, it is reasonable to withhold information until its planned release. The list as at 31/07/22 will be placed on the website after City's 2021/22 Financial Statements have been audited and approved by City's Council.

Response Text

Dear Millie Sullivan

Freedom of Information Act 2000 – Your Request

Thank you for your email requesting information about City, University of London (“City”, “we”, “us” or “our”), which was received by us on 4th October 2022 (“your Request”).

Your Request has been considered under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (“the FOIA 2000”).

For ease of reference, the questions within your Request are reproduced below in bold followed by our responses in italics.

In the annual investment policy that is distributed amongst the City council, it makes clear that "external investment management" is used in a majority of City’s investments, including endowment funds.

Please can you provide:

1) A detailed list of the names of these investment management companies or individuals

City’s investment managers are UBS.

2) the amount that the University gives them to manage and the returns on these investments

We can confirm that we do hold information that falls within the description of your Request.

Please note, however, that this information has been withheld by City on the following grounds:

City considers the information requested about the management and the returns on City’s investments to be exempt information under section 43(2) of the FOIA 2000, as we consider that disclosure of this information would be likely to prejudice City’s commercial interests.

Section 43(2) is subject to the public interest test as follows:

The arguments for disclosure are:

City recognises the interest in our financial matters as a provider of higher education, as well as our general obligations of transparency and openness as a public authority.

Additionally, City recognises that there is a public interest in the disclosure of information which facilitates the accountability and transparency of public bodies for decisions taken by them.

The arguments against disclosure are:

The specific details of the investments reflect the professional decisions made by the fund managers, who were appointed on the basis of their ability to make appropriate decisions in accordance with the University’s needs, values and objectives.

Disclosure of specific information about City’s investment management and returns , into the public domain would or would likely to prejudice the commercial interests of City, as a competitor within higher education might use the information to gain a competitive advantage, as the market in which they operate, is one in which investment decisions and assets weightings are commercial material.

Outcome of public interest test

In conclusion City considers that there is a balance to be maintained, and accepts that, as a publicly-funded body. It should be transparent in relation to its financial matters. However, this must be weighed against the University’s need to secure high-quality, yet cost-effective advice in relation to its investments, to protect the financial stability of the University.

Disclosure of detailed information about the investments could prejudice the University’s competitive edge, by revealing details of a key area of City’s investment and commercial strategy.

For these reasons, City believes Section 43(2) applies and the reasons against disclosure outweigh the public interest in releasing this information at this point in time.

3) the types of investments that they manage

UBS manage the investments relating to City’s working capital cash (in the form of deposits held with highly rated counterparty financial institutions) and endowment and restricted reserves (in the form of bonds, equities, real estate and cash investments).

4) And if available, a list of the companies/organisations/investments made on behalf of the university by these investors.

For the values as at 31st July 2021, Please see link at:

https://www.city.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/651065/Investments-listing-as-at- 31.07.21.pdf

5) Please may the response be categorised in that order, and may this please be for the last five financial years.

City can only supply the investment information in the list above (please refer question 4), as we have only been collating and publishing this data since then.

We can confirm that we do hold information that falls within the description of your Request for the last financial year.

Please note, however, that this information has been withheld by City on the following grounds:

City considers the information requested about the companies/organisations/investments made on behalf of the University to be exempt information under Section 22 of the FOIA 2000. City intends for the information to be published and accessible online to the public at a future date and, that, in all circumstances, it is reasonable to withhold information until its planned release. The list as at 31/07/22 will be placed on the website after City's 2021/22 Financial Statements have been audited and approved by City's Council.

Section 22 is subject to the public interest test as follows:

The arguments for disclosure are:

City recognises the interest in our financial matters as a provider of higher education, as well as our general obligations of transparency and openness as a public authority.

Additionally, City recognises that there is a public interest in the disclosure of information which facilitates the accountability and transparency of public bodies for decisions taken by them.

The arguments against disclosure are:

There is a public interest in City's Financial Statements being properly audited and approved by our governing body, prior to release of the information into the public domain via publication on our website. The release of unaudited and unapproved Financial Statements into the public domain, in response to your Request, may result in the release of inaccurate or incorrect information being released and relied upon by other parties - a situation that controls such as auditing and approval by the University's governing body are intended to prevent. Among other risks, this may result in damage to City's reputation and standing as a higher education provider and public authority, which is not in the public interest.

The list as at 31/07/22 will be placed on the website after the 2021/22 Financial Statements have been audited and approved by Council.

Outcome of public interest test

In conclusion City considers that there is a balance to be maintained, and accepts that, as a public authority City should be transparent in relation to its financial matters. However, this must be weighed against the University’s future plans to publish the information and ensure accurate information is released into the public domain in order to protect both the reputation and financial stability of the University.

For these reasons, City believes Section 22 applies and the reasons against disclosure outweigh the public interest in releasing this information at this point in time.

Complaints

Please note that City has a formal complaints and internal review process.

If you are dissatisfied with the manner in which your Request has been managed, please contact us in writing, describing your Request, explaining your grounds for dissatisfaction and including an address for correspondence to:

Information Assurance Team Leader

City, University of London

Northampton Square

London EC1V 0HB

By Telephone: 0207 040 4000

By Email: [email protected]

Please note that any complaint and/or request for an internal review should be received by City within 40 working days of the date of this letter; City is not obliged to consider any complaint or request for an internal review that is received outside of this period.

If, after contacting City, you are still dissatisfied with the outcome, you have a right of appeal to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO):

By Post:

Information Commissioner's Office

Wycliffe House

Water Lane

Wilmslow

Cheshire

SK9 5AF

By Telephone: 01625 545700

Website: www.ico.org.uk

Data sources

Source

This is an FoI request submitted by dED staff