Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
In the below request the phrase the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
1.BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Boeing
‘Academic partnership’ refers to ‘arms trade companies’ involvement of any of the following:
• Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances
• Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships
• Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research.
• Any consultancy role.
Please may I request any relevant information or appearance of arms trade companies in the aforementioned capacities in the past five years:
• May this be broken down by financial year, with the start/end date where applicable
• The name of the arms company involved
• The financial value of the relationship
• The name of the relevant university department
• The name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship
Many Thanks,
Millie
Response Refusal Reason
Under section 43 of the FOIA, concerning public information, stating that releasing the information would have negative detriment to their position as a public enterprise.
Response Text
Dear Millie Sullivan,
Further to our letter dated 19th October 2023, we thank you for your patience whilst we used the extra
time to consider the public interest under the exemptions Section 41: ‘Information provided in confidence’
and Section 43 ‘Commercial Interests’ in relation to your request received on 22nd September 2023 has
now been considered. The response to your request is as follows:
In the below request the phrase the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
1.BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Boeing
‘Academic partnership’ refers to ‘arms trade companies’ involvement of any of the following:
• Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances
• Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships
• Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for
doctoral research.
• Any consultancy role.
Northumbria University
Pandon Building
Newcastle Upon Tyne
NE1 8ST
Information Rights Coordinator
Sarah Owen
W: northumbria.ac.uk
Please may I request any relevant information or appearance of arms trade companies in the
aforementioned capacities in the past five years:
• May this be broken down by financial year, with the start/end date where applicable
• The name of the arms company involved
• The financial value of the relationship
• The name of the relevant university department
• The name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship
We can confirm that some of the information you requested is held by Northumbria University in relation
to some of the listed organisations, but, but it is considered exempt from disclosure because it falls under
the exemptions in section 41 of the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) relating to ‘Information Provided
in Confidence’ and section 43 relating to ‘Commercial Interests’.
In the case of section 43 there is a ‘public interest test’ to apply because section 43 is a qualified
exemption. Section 41 is an absolute exemption and so there is no public interest test to apply, though
in effect there is still a requirement to consider the public interest in disclosure, because the law of
confidence recognises that a breach of confidence may not be actionable when there is an overriding
public interest in disclosure.
Section 41 (Confidentiality):
Information is covered by Section 41 if:
• it was obtained by the Council from another person,
• its disclosure would constitute a breach of confidence.
• a legal person could bring a court action for that breach of confidence, and
• that court action would be likely to succeed.
When determining if disclosure would constitute a breach of confidence, we have considered:
• whether the withheld information has the quality of confidence,
• whether it was imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence,
• and
• whether disclosure would be an unauthorised use of the withheld information to the
detriment of the named organisations.
Quality of Confidence
Information will possess the necessary quality of confidence if:
• it is more than trivial; and
• not otherwise accessible.
The information should be worthy of protection in the sense that someone has a genuine interest in the
contents remaining confidential.
The preservation of confidences is recognised by the courts to be an important matter and one in which
there is a strong public interest.
Information that is already in the public domain won’t possess the necessary quality of confidence. In the
case of commercial confidentiality, confidentiality will be permanently lost if the information has entered
the public domain at any time. However, if disclosure would reveal something new, then the material that
would bring the new information to light may still retain its quality of confidence.
Some of the requested information relates to partnerships with some of the named organisations that
have been publicly announced on our website, but the financial arrangements or the specific nature of,
for example, joint research projects have been disclosed. The fact that part of the requested information,
has been disclosed in these instances should not be taken as definitive proof that the undisclosed details
requested don’t have the necessary quality of confidence.
Therefore, in this case the fact that we have previously announced partnerships with some of the
organisations does not necessarily mean that we must now disclose further information about that
partnership if it would be considered a breach of confidence.
Further to this, where a partnership has not been announced, by confirming the identity of the
organisations that do not have a relationship with the University would, when compared with those that
have been announced, identify any relationships that are not in the publica domain. This form of
identification would itself be a breach of confidence in that it would, by definition, confirm a relationship
where the existence of the relationship itself is covered by the non-disclosure agreement.
The Obligation of Confidence
An obligation of confidence may apply if the confider has attached explicit conditions to any subsequent
use or disclosure of the information (for example in the form of contractual terms). We can confirm that
the University is bound by nondisclosure agreements in relation to some of these relationships and that
disclosing the existence of the relationship would itself be a breach of such contractual arrangements.
Detriment to the organisations
As the withheld information is commercial in nature, disclosure will constitute a breach of confidence if it
would or would be likely to have a detrimental impact on any of the organisations listed. For example,
providing the details of a research project and the amount paid to the University could have a detrimental
impact on the organisation through the disclosure of information that could be used by competitor
organisations.
Actionable Breach of Confidence
Section 41(b) provides that the breach of confidence must be actionable by any of the organisations.
Here a partner organisation could bring an action against the University for breach of confidence and
breach of contract. Our view is that any work conducted under an express obligation of confidence
makes a strong case that disclosure of the withheld information would amount to an actionable breach
of confidence by the University.
The final part of the test for engaging section 41 is whether the action for breach of confidence is likely
to succeed. Our view is that legal action by any organisation for breach of confidence would be likely to
succeed because the confidentiality obligations set out in the nondisclosure agreement are clear and
legally binding, and we are not obliged to disclose the information under FOIA by virtue of the absolute
confidentiality exemption under section 41 and the qualified exemption under section 43.
We also consider that any such action would be likely to succeed because in the absence of a clear legal
obligation on the University to disclose the withheld information under FOIA, the University would be in
breach of contract, specifically in breach of its obligations of confidentiality towards the organisation.
Also, as explained further below we do not consider that there is a public interest defence to the
disclosure.
Public Interest
Section 43 is an absolute exemption, so we do not need to apply the public interest test. However, we
still need to consider the public interest in disclosure, because the law of confidence recognises that a
breach of confidence may not be actionable when there is an overriding public interest in disclosure.
The test is whether there is a public interest in disclosure which overrides the competing public interest
in maintaining the duty of confidence. This test doesn’t function in the same way as the public interest
test for qualified exemptions, where the public interest operates in favour of disclosure unless outweighed
by the public interest in maintaining the exemption.
The test assumes that the public interest in maintaining confidentiality will prevail unless the public
interest in disclosure outweighs the public interest in maintaining the confidence. Our view is that there
is no compelling public interest here in disclosure that overrides the competing public interest in
maintaining the legal duty of confidence that the University owes to partner organisations.
The key public interest factors inherent in this part of the test for Section 41 are the general public interest
in ensuring that public authorities remain transparent, accountable and open to scrutiny, for example
where disclosure would facilitate accountability and transparency in the spending of public money.
When considering the public interest in favour of maintaining the confidence, we have paid particular
regard to the wider public interest in preserving the principle of confidentiality, and the impact of
disclosure on the interests of the partner organisations.
In particular, the disclosure of the withheld information will undermine the principle of confidentiality and
the relationship of trust between the University and partners, and individuals and organisations may be
discouraged from confiding in the University, and other public authorities subject to FOIA, if they don’t
have a degree of certainty that this trust will be respected.
In respect of commercial impact, this carries weight because the requested information relates to
university income rather than University expenditure and the breach of confidence would damage the
University and our competitive position and ability to attract funding for research and studentships.
because disclosure would reveal information that would assist competitor in terms of who we receive
income from and what types of research we are undertaking, and it would undermine our future
negotiations with other organisations.
Section 43 (Commercial interests):
Section 43(2) exempts information whose disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the
commercial interests of any legal person (an individual, a company, the public authority itself or any other
legal entity).
Section 43 applies because the University considers that the release of this information could prejudice
the commercial interests of the University because the requested information provides details of
organisations with whom we have established contractual partnerships to deliver research and/or
studentships which contribute to the income of the University. We believe that, as discussed above, the
disclosure of any information that would lead to a breach of confidence could discourage other companies
from funding future projects or studentships and thus negatively impact upon our income streams.
Section 43 is a qualified exemptions under the FOIA, Northumbria University is required to balance the
public interest in withholding the information against the public interest in disclosing it.
The factors considered when deciding the public interest in disclosing the information include:
We acknowledge that there is a public interest in understanding the sources of income that Public
Authorities access and that there can be general concerns associated with the types of organisations
they may enter into partnership with. Disclosure of information could provide a general compliance with
the principles of openness and transparency and help raise awareness of the Higher Education sectors
funding activities.
The factors considered when deciding the public interest in withholding the information include:
Providing information in response to a Freedom of Information Act request is akin to publishing the
information for the world to see, therefore any information released would be considered ‘in the public
domain’ and accessible to other Universities and or rival organisations of our partners.
It is the current policy of the Government that the higher education market should be competitive in the
interests of students and the wider public. As such, the Higher Education sector has become increasingly
competitive, and UK Universities are now in direct competition with one another and international
Universities when attempting to attract students to study at an institution. The Information Tribunal has
acknowledged that universities have commercial interests (EA/2009/0034) and that UK Universities
operate in a global market that sees student recruitment as a recognised commercial activity for any
University
Where the university has entered contracts that prohibit the disclosure of information withing the scope
of the partnerships, any breaches of confidentiality could damage future relationships with existing or
future partners who may be unwilling to risk working with the UK Higher Education sector for fear of
confidential information being disclosed via the FOIA. This would negatively impact both Northumbria
University and the wider UK Higher Education Sector in terms of seeking future funding.
The nature of the research would be of interest to rival organisations, nations or other Universities and
could enable competitors to invest in their own areas of research. Thus, undermining the commercial
interests of both the partners and the University who could lose the expected return on investment
from the research.
We therefore do not believe that the public interest is served in neither confirming nor denying that the
information is held or in withholding the information.
If you are unhappy with our response or the way your request has been handled, you have the right to
ask for an internal review. To request a review, please contact the Records and Information Manager,
in writing at the above address or via email. The review would be undertaken by Jay Wilson, the
University’s Head of Legal.
Please remember to quote the reference number above in any future communications.
Should you remain dissatisfied following an internal review, you may then appeal to the Information
Commissioner at www.ico.org.uk
Yours sincerely
Sarah Owen
Information Rights Coordinator