Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
In the below request the phrase the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
-
BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Boeing
‘Academic partnership’ refers to ‘arms trade companies’ involvement of any of the following:
• Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances
• Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships
• Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research.
• Any consultancy role.
Please may I request any relevant information or appearance of arms trade companies in the aforementioned capacities in the past five years:
May this be broken down by financial year, with the start/end date where applicable
- The name of the arms company involved
- The financial value of the relationship
- The name of the relevant university department
- The name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship
Many Thanks,
Millie
Response Refusal Reason
Redactions
Response Text
Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002
Our Ref: 548-23
I refer to your enquiry dated 19 December 2023 under the Freedom of Information (Scotland)
Act 2002 (FOISA). You have asked to be supplied with details of the listed ‘arms trade
companies’ involvement over the past five years in academic partnerships as detailed below:
• Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances;
• Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships;
• Company involvement in university departments i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC
centres for doctoral research; and
• Any consultancy role.
Arms trade companies
-
BAE systems 11. Lockheed Martin
-
Babcock 12. Thales
-
QuinetiQ 13. MBDA
-
Rolls-Royce 14. Elbit Systems
-
Serco 15. Caterpillar
-
Cobham 16. MOD
-
Raytheon 17. DSTL
-
Airbus 18. Atomic Weapons establishment
-
General Dynamics 19. GKN
-
Leonardo MW 20. Boeing
May this be broken down by financial year, with the start/end date where applicable
• The name of the arms company involved
• The financial value of the relationship
• The name of the relevant university department
• The name and description of the research being conducted in the studentship
Please find attached Appendix A which provides details of research projects and interactions
with our Careers Centre involving any of the above listed companies.
The exact value of two research projects is being withheld under section 33(1)(b),
Commercial Interests of the FOISA and instead the figure is presented in a band range. The
rationale for applying this exemption is set out below.
i. Identify whether a commercial interest exists
BAE Systems Ltd is a private company that participates in a commercial activity and they
have a commercial interest in the information being withheld.
ii. Would disclosure of the information in question be harmful?
The withheld details are not publicly available and the company believes that disclosure
would have a detrimental impact on their commercial interests, allowing competitors to
identify the level of activity and the exact amount invested by the company in research
projects.
The research agreement attached to the funding from BAE Systems Ltd is subject to
confidentiality provisions. In line with the Section 60 Code of Practice on compliance with
the FOISA, BAE Systems Ltd were consulted as a third party on the disclosure of the
requested information and consent was not given for the exact amount of funding received
from them to be disclosed on the grounds that they consider this information to be
commercially confidential, disclosure of which would be harmful to their ability to operate
effectively, significantly weakening their position in a highly competitive environment.
On reaching this conclusion, the University has been guided by Decision 042/2017 Mr
Gary Barwood and the Scottish Futures Trust which concerned rates of return and revenue
payments made under contract. In this Decision it was accepted that information subject to
contractual agreements between public authorities and third parties relates directly to their
commercial interests.
iii. Application of the public interest test
The application of this exemption is subject to the public interest test. There is a public
interest in private companies being able to trade fairly and to provide a viable business in
a competitive market. It is also in the public interest that commercial companies are not
treated unfairly as a result of having entered into a contractual arrangement with a public
body. This public interest must be balanced against that in transparency and
accountability of public bodies which the University believes can be met through the level
of information that is being made available as part of this response.
On balance, the University is of the view that the level of information being disclosed
meets the public interest in terms of financial accountability without placing BAE Systems
Ltd at any significant disadvantage and it would be contrary to the public interest to go
beyond this level of disclosure. The withholding of the two figures is therefore applicable
under section 33(1)(b) Commercial Interests of the FOISA.
Information not held
I can confirm that no academic partnerships have been identified during the specified
reporting period with the following companies:
• Babcock • Elbit Systems
• Serco • Caterpillar
• Cobham • Raytheon
• Airbus • Boeing
• General Dynamics • GKN
Section 17 of the FOISA requires that a Scottish public authority confirms in writing where
information requested of it is not held and notice is therefore given in this regard.
Your right to seek a review of how your information request was managed
If you are not satisfied with the University’s response and/or our reasoning set-out above, you
have the right to request a review of our decision. The timelines in which this right is available
are set out in section 20(5)(a) and (b) FOISA. In broad terms the right to seek a review must
be exercised within 40 working days of receiving this response.
Any request for review at this time should be sent by email to [email protected] stating:
a) your name and address;
b) details of your original request; and
c) the reasons why you are dissatisfied with our response.
If you remain dissatisfied with how your request for information has been dealt with following
Review, you also have the right to apply to the Scottish Information Commissioner (SIC) for a
decision. In the event of an appeal to the SIC, the Commissioner will generally only be able
to investigate the matters raised in the request for review.
Details on how to make an appeal online to the SIC can be found on their website:
http://www.itspublicknowledge.info/YourRights/Unhappywiththeresponse/AppealingtoCommis
sioner.aspx .
This concludes the University’s response.
Yours sincerely
JUNE WEIR