Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:
1.BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Boeing
In the below request, the phrase ‘research project' related to, but not limited to:
Any academic research collaborations that involve any staff members or any member of the active student body with companies or institutions who have stakes in the defence industry and arms trade companies.
Could you please provide me with all research projects with any connection to arms trade companies in the last five years. Connections can include sources of funding and/or collaborative research partnership on the research project.
Please can these be broken down by financial year, and categorise them accordingly:
- Title and aim of research project
- Players (list of companies involved in the research project)
- Name of university department(s) involved (if applicable)
- Source of funding for the research project (to be included the source of funding does not have to be an arms trade company)
- The total amount, in pounds sterling, that the university has received in research funding for this project in the last five financial years. Details should be broken down for this project year-by-year.
- Timescale of research project - start and end (exact day/month if applicable/available, otherwise by financial years)
Many thanks,
Millie
Response Refusal Reason
Section 26(3) of the FOIA which states the exemption from duty to response if the response would prejudice the defence of the british islands or of any colony, or prejudice the capability of, effectiveness or securty of any relevant forces.
Response Text
Monday 5 February 2024
Refusal notice to Freedom of Information (FOI) request, 08 January 2024
Dear Ms Sullivan,
- This letter is being sent in response to your Freedom of Information (FOI) request,
received by the University of Winchester on 08 January 2024.
- This letter will explain why the University is refusing to neither confirm nor deny if we hold
information relating to your request.
- You requested the following:
“Could you please provide me with all research projects with any connection to arms trade
companies in the last five years. Connections can include sources of funding and/or
collaborative research partnership on the research project.
Please can these be broken down by financial year, and categorise them accordingly:
• Title and aim of research project
• Players (list of companies involved in the research project)
• Name of university department(s) involved (if applicable)
• Source of funding for the research project (to be included the source of funding does not have
to be an arms trade company)
• The total amount, in pounds sterling, that the university has received in research funding for this project in the last five financial years. Details should be broken down for this project year-by-year.
• Timescale of research project - start and end (exact day/month if applicable/available, otherwise
by financial years)”
- You also provided a list of 20 companies which you identified as ‘arms trade companies’
but stated that the request was not limited to these.
- The University believes that your request for this information falls within the Section 26(3)
exemption of the Freedom of Information Act on ‘Defence’
- The ICO guidance on ‘Defence’ states: “Section 26(1)(a) provides an exemption for
information if its disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the defence of the British
Islands or of any colony. Section 26(1)(b) provides an exemption for information if its
disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the capability of, effectiveness or security
of any relevant forces. Section26(3) provides an exemption from the duty to confirm or
deny whether information is held if doing so would, or would be likely to, prejudices any of
the matters mentions in subsection 26(1).’
- Before applying this exemption, the University considered the timing of the request, the
age of the information and information which may already be in the public domain. We
determined that if information of this nature was held by the University that it would fall
under the Section 26(1) exemption because the information requested was specifically
related to research projects connected to companies who provide proprietary technology
to the British armed forces. The timescale of the request would include research material
which may already have been included in technology supplied to the MoD and could be in
use in current defence systems or it could include material intended for future deployment
or implementation. Research material of this nature is not generally published.
- Section 26(3) is a “qualified exemption” for an FOI and is subject to a public interest test.
The University will consider both the arguments in favour of disclosing the information
requested and the arguments in favour of non-disclosure.
Arguments in Favour of Disclosing the Information Requested:
- Openness and transparency - the University notes that “Public authorities should bear in
mind the strong case for openness and transparency in their affairs when balancing public
interest arguments”. Releasing information of this kind could contribute to a wider
understanding in the public of what universities do in terms of research and business
engagement.
- Demilitarising education is an important and emotive issue and discussion of this topic
should be encouraged within the public arena. Information of the kind requested could
contribute to the public debate.
- Information relating to research projects carried out by arms trade companies which may
possibly be used within technology and hardware used within the British armed forces
would inform the public and possibly enhance the public’s confidence in the UK’s defence
capabilities and effectiveness.
Arguments in Favour of Maintaining the Exemption:
- Information relating to research projects carried out by arms trade companies, including
the name and aim of the project, could directly relate to measures currently deployed or
intended for future deployment, within hardware and software systems used by the British
armed forces. This would be likely to jeopardise the effectiveness of these systems by
enabling hostile nations and other enemy combatants to gain insight into the capabilities
of the British forces and possibly develop counter measures. This in turn could jeopardise
the safety and security of military personnel across the globe and possibly the lives of
civilians.
- Confirming if research projects are undertaken by any university, for companies that
produce equipment and systems for the armed forces, would be likely to expose those
Universities to increased cyber-attacks from hostile nations who may see universities as
easy targets to gain proprietary information. Universities have already been advised by
the National Cyber Security Centre that they are experiencing a higher level of cyber-
attacks since the UK Government imposed sanctions on Russia2
- If such research contracts were in place, it is reasonable to assume that there would be
confidentiality measures in place to protect the information about military projects.
Releasing any information in breach of these measures would be highly likely to lay the
university open to legal action from these companies. This would lead to reputational
damage to the university and possibly loss of confidence in the university as a research
partner. This would result in loss of revenue to the university and loss of research
opportunities for university staff.
The Public Interest Test
- Paragraph 67 of the ICO’s ‘The Public Interest Test’3 states that: “Public authorities must
then carry out a balancing exercise to decide whether the public interest in maintaining
the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosure. If it does not, the information
must be released”. In the present case, after an analysis of your FOI request, as the public
authority concerned, with this balancing exercise I believe that the public interest in
maintaining the exemption for the request outweighs the public interest in disclosure.
Conclusion
- The ICO’s Guide to FOI states4
: “In the refusal notice you should:
a) explain what provision of the Act you are relying on to refuse the request and
why;
b) give details of any internal review (complaints) procedure you offer or state that
you do not have one; and,
c) explain the requester’s right to complain to the ICO, including contact details for
this”
- On the first point, “explain what provision of the Act you are relying on to refuse the request
and why”: the University believes your request falls within section 26(3).
- On the second point, “give details of any internal review procedure you offer or state that
you do not have one”: If you would like to make a request for an internal review, please
email [email protected]
- On the third point, “explain the requester’s right to complain to the ICO, including contact
details for this”: The ICO can be contacted through various channels as noted at
https://ico.org.uk/make-a-complaint/ Such channels would include calling the ICO helpline
on: 0303 123 1113.
Yours sincerely,
Melanie Short
Information Compliance Officer