Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
In the below request the phrase the phrase 'arms trade companies' relates to, but not limited to:
-
BAE systems
-
Babcock
-
QinetiQ
-
Rolls-Royce
-
Serco
-
Cobham
-
Raytheon
-
Airbus
-
General Dynamics
-
Leonardo MW
-
Lockheed Martin
-
Thales
-
MBDA
-
Elbit Systems
-
Caterpillar
-
MOD
-
DSTL
-
Atomic Weapons establishment
-
GKN
-
Boeing
'Academic partnership' refers to 'arms trade companies' involvement of any of the following:
* Graduate schemes/apprenticeships/Careers fair appearances
* Directly sponsored PhDs or Studentships
* Company involvement in university departments - i.e. MoD Laboratories, EPSRC centres for doctoral research.
* Any consultancy role.
Please may I request any relevant information or appearance of arms trade companies in the aforementioned capacities in the past five years:
May this be broken down by financial year, with the start/end date where applicable
-
The name of the arms company involved
-
The financial value of the relationship
-
The name of the relevant university department
Many Thanks,
Millie
Response Refusal Reason
Part redaction of the information under section 43(2) of the FOI act to protect the commercial interests of the university against prejudice. Parts were also redacted under section 12 of the FOI act, which limits the research time of the responder to 18hours maximum
Response Text
Further to your email dated 5 April 2024 requesting information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, the University has considered your request. In accordance with Section 17(1) of the Freedom of Information Act, this response also acts as a Refusal Notice in response to part of your request.
Consultancy Roles The University is unable to provide information on consultancy roles with the companies specified in the request within the Fees Limit (Section 12). The information requested is not stored in a central and easily retrievable location. To provide the information requested the University would need to contact all departments at the University to see if any consultancy had taken place with the companies listed in the request and whether it falls into the scope of the request. Given the size of the University and the period specified this would take a considerable amount of time. Therefore, provision of the information would take the University over the Fees Limit. Please see Refusal Notice below.
Apprenticeships In relation to apprenticeships the University provides the following programmes with the companies listed in the request.
Company Programme Date Value DSTL Level 6 Data
Scientist
September 2023 – June 2027
Level 6 Chartered Manager
September 2018 – October 2022
Level 6 Chartered Manager
January 2019 – January 2023
Rolls Royce
Level 6 Chartered October 2022 –
The University deems this information to be exempt by virtue of Section 43 (2).
Manager September 2026
Whilst the University confirms it holds information pertaining to the value of the relationship, this information will not be provided as it is exempt by virtue of Section 43 (2) Commercial Interests. Please see Refusal Notice below
However, outside of the Fees Limit the University can provide the following information.
Graduate Schemes/Careers Fair Appearances In relation to employability events hosted by the University please see the attached spreadsheet, which shows the companies listed in the request who were in attendance. Job fairs throughout the year are an opportunity for the companies in attendance to recruit University students to their organisation including their graduate schemes.
Directly Sponsored PhDs or Studentships The University does not have any funded PhD studentships with the organisations specified in the request.
Company Involvement in University Departments Please see the attached spreadsheet which shows the 12 projects that involve 4 of the companies specified in the request. In all instances, the company is the funder of the research, but the University is not always the lead organisation receiving the funding. Refusal Notice – Fees Limit (Section 12)
Under the Freedom of Information Act (“the Act”), Section 12, the University is not under a duty to comply with a request where it estimates that the cost of doing so would exceed the limit of £450, calculated in accordance with the Regulations made under the Freedom of Information Act at £25 per person per hour for a total of 18 hours (The Freedom of Information and Data Protection (Appropriate Limit and Fees) Regulations 2004. In estimating whether the cost of complying with any request exceeds the limit of £450, the University is entitled to consider the costs it reasonably expects to incur in the information- retrieval process e.g. locating the information (or a document containing it), retrieving the information (or a document containing it) and extracting the information from a document containing it. For the reasons set out above, the University has estimated that complying with your request would exceed the prescribed limit and is, therefore, under no obligation to disclose any of the requested information.
Refusal Notice – Commercial Interests 43(2) The Section 43(2) exemption applies in this respect as information is exempt if its disclosure under the FOIA would, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of any person/company (this can include the University). The University has concluded that releasing the information requested is likely to prejudice the University’s and the employer’s commercial interests, as it would release commercially sensitive information into the public domain.
The higher education sector is a very competitive environment, with competition between institutions ever increasing. To enable the University to compete in the higher education market, the University must ensure that information pertinent to its strategy and therefore useful to its competitors is not released into the public domain. The University provides a highly successful apprenticeship programme. Securing high quality apprenticeship contracts with employers is vital to its success and directly impacts on the University’s ability to recruit high quality students to its programmes. Student recruitment is a highly competitive activity in the Higher Education Sector and as such the University considers that to release information pertinent to its apprenticeships strategy would compromise the University’s ability to attract high quality students to its course and would provide other institutions with key information.
Additionally, the University has negotiated specific and unique contracts with the employers who have apprentices enrolled on its programmes. These employers would not expect their details to be released into the public domain as it may reduce their ability to secure future contracts with other Universities. Furthermore, it would undermine the University’s ability to attract potential employers for future apprenticeship programmes and would reduce its likelihood of securing employers with competitive terms for its services. Disclosure, therefore, is likely to materially reduce the University’s commercial advantage in the HE Sector.
The exemption relating to Section 43(2) is subject to the Public Interest Test under the legislation. In consideration of the Public Interest Test, the University must consider whether the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in withholding the information. The University has considered that the public interest favours withholding the information in the circumstances relating to your request. In reaching the decision, the University identified the following factors as to why disclosure might be in the public interest but considered that they were outweighed by the reasons set out above in this response against disclosure; these factors were:
• Promoting accountability and transparency in decisions made by the University; and • Furthering the understanding of the University’s apprenticeships activities If you feel that the University has misunderstood your request in any way or you are dissatisfied with the response to your request, you can request an internal review by contacting [email protected] within 40 working days of the date of this response. Further information on the University’s internal review procedure under Freedom of
Information can be found at https://www.ntu.ac.uk/about-us/governance/freedom-of- information.
You also have the right, under Section 50 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 to apply to the Information Commission for a decision as to whether your request for information has been dealt with in accordance with the requirements of Part 1 of the Act. The Commissioner will, however, normally require you to pursue an internal appeal to the University prior to considering such an application. You can find further information about the Act from the Information Commissioner at https://ico.org.uk/. Please quote the reference number 1636541 in any future communications.
Kind regards,
<hr />To whom it may concern
Many thanks for your response. In this Response, you mention an attached spreadsheet concerning company involvement in departments and careers fair appearances. However this has not been attached.
Please may you send over the mentioned spreadsheet
Many thanks Millie
<hr />Dear Ms Sullivan
Please accept my apologies but the spreadsheet was not attached to the response sent out to you last week.
Please find attached the spreadsheet to go with the response.
Kind Regards
Abi