See how much your university is linked to the arms trade →

Freedom of Information (FoI) Request

Request Date
2 Feb, 2024
Response Date
11 Mar, 2024
Provision
None
Military Links
No

Request Text

To whom it may concern

In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies’ relates to, but not limited to:

1.BAE systems

  1. Babcock

  2. QinetiQ

  3. Rolls-Royce

  4. Serco

  5. Cobham

  6. Raytheon

  7. Airbus

  8. General Dynamics

  9. Leonardo MW

  10. Lockheed Martin

  11. Thales

  12. MBDA

  13. Elbit Systems

  14. Caterpillar

  15. MOD

  16. DSTL

  17. Atomic Weapons establishment

  18. GKN

  19. Boeing Please may you provide:

1) Any investment made into an arms trade company, detailing the name of the arms trade company/organisation, amount invested, and type of investment (e.g. bonds, stocks and shares, capital etc.) of that financial year, for the past five financial years.

2) Any investment made into an arms trade company by the university endowment fund organised by name of company/organisation, amount invested of that financial year, for the past five financial years

3.) The name of any investment management firm or bank the university uses to make investments, and the amount given to them annually. If they do provide a list of the names of companies/organisations/investments they make on the university’s behalf, please include any investments in arms trade companies provided by this information.

Many thanks,

Millie

Response Text

Dear Millie

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2000 - INFORMATION REQUEST

Your request for information has been considered under the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act and our response is as follows:

We are refusing this request on the basis of Section 12(1) of the Freedom of Information Act ‘Cost of Compliance Exceeds the Appropriate Limit’.

In relation to the wording of your request ‘relates to, but not limited to…’, the university do not label companies as ‘arms trade’ or ‘military’. We would therefore have to conduct extensive further research into every investment to ensure we had captured any company that may be considered relevant. I would like to highlight that De Montfort University (DMU) have an investment policy that commits to screening out arms companies in line with our ‘Environmental, Social and Governance’ goals (Investment Policy (dmu.ac.uk)).

Also, DMU holdings can change on a daily basis. In order to be able to confirm whether we had investments or endowments with specific companies for the time period you requested, we would have to review every single day of the past five years to confirm whether we had any holdings at that specific point. We would also have to involve the third parties who manage investments and endowments to undertake this on our behalf.

If the University cannot locate, retrieve and extract some or all of the requested information within the 18 hours we are not obliged to retrieve any of the requested information.

In line with our Section 16 ‘Duty to provide assistance and advice’, we have the following suggestions for ways that you can narrow the scope of a new request that might enable it to be answered within the 18-hour appropriate limit.

  • Provide a list of specific companies that you would like the university to search for investment information about (or limit it to the companies named in your original request).
  • Be more specific in the timeframe of your request. We would be able to confirm whether we are invested in specific companies on the day of the request for current investments. We may also be able to confirm whether or not there were any investments in specific named companies on a certain date, such as the end of last month or on 2nd February 2023 for example.

Please be aware that even if you take the advice we have given above, we cannot guarantee that the new request you make would be answerable within the 18 hours so it may be refused again. It would depend on the nature and scope of that new request alone. Whilst you are not obliged to, it might help if you highlighted key questions you would like us to focus on answering – perhaps listing them in order of importance in your request – or a specific period of time to start with e.g. start with information from 2021 and work backwards until the 18-hour limit is reached. This may increase the likelihood of you receiving some of the information you are interested in at least.

Please note, you have the right to complain to the University about this decision.  If you wish to request an internal review of this decision, or any other matter connected to your request, please let me know.

If you are subsequently not satisfied with the University’s response to your complaint you have a right of appeal to the Information Commissioner’s Office at Make a complaint | ICO Please note the Information Commissioner’s Office will expect you to have gone through DMU’s review process before the matter is escalated to them.

Yours sincerely,

Janette Ratcliffe

-----

To whom it may concern,

Thank you for you response. As per your advice, I would like to limit the request to the specific listed companies, and also as per your advice, do you have any current investments in these mentioned companies from this date (28/02/2024)

Many thanks,

Millie

<hr />

Dear Millie

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2000 - INFORMATION REQUEST

Your request for information has been considered under the requirements of the Freedom of Information Act and our response is as follows:

1)               Any investment made into the named arms trade company, detailing the name of the arms trade company/organisation, amount invested, and type of investment (e.g. bonds, stocks and shares, capital etc.) on the date of the request.

2)                Any investment made into the named arms trade company by the university endowment fund organised by name of company/organisation on the date of the request.

As part of your right to be informed under section 1(1)(a) of the Freedom of Information Act, I can confirm that we do not hold information that could answer either of your questions. This is because De Montfort University did not have any investments or endowments with the named companies on the date requested.

If you have any queries, please get in touch with me to discuss them.

Please note that the information provided may contain information that is protected by copyright and there may be restrictions on any further re-use of this, please contact us if you are unsure whether a further use of the information would be lawful. Further details can be found here.

Please note, you have the right to complain to the University about this response.  If you wish to request an internal review of this decision, or any other matter connected to your request, please contact me within two months of the date of this response. If you ask for an internal review, it would be helpful if you could say why you are dissatisfied with the response you received.

If you are subsequently not satisfied with the University’s response to your complaint you have a right of appeal to the Information Commissioner’s Office. The primary way of doing this is via the complaints’ portal at FOI and EIR complaints | ICO. Alternative methods of contacting the Information Commissioner’s Office can be found at Make a complaint | ICO. Please note that the Information Commissioner’s Office will expect you to have gone through DMU’s review process before the matter is escalated to them.

Yours sincerely,

Janette Ratcliffe

Data sources

Source

This is an FoI request submitted by dED staff