Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Thank you for your assistance with my previous request. Please find below a separate request under the Freedom of Information Act of 2000.
In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists. This includes but is not limited to:
- BAE systems
- Babcock
- QinetiQ
- Rolls-Royce
- Serco
- Cobham
- Raytheon (RTX)
- Airbus
- General Dynamics
- Leonardo MW
- Lockheed Martin
- Thales
- MBDA
- Elbit Systems
- Northrop Grumman
- L3 Harris Technologies
- General Electric
- AVIC
- GKN Aerospace
- Boeing
- Ministry of Defence (MoD)
- Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl)
- Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
If you are unable to run the request for the full list of companies attached, please treat the above list as complete.
In the below request, the phrase ‘research project' is related to, but not limited to:
Any academic research collaborations that involve any staff members or any member of the active student body with companies or institutions who have stakes in the defence industry and arms trade companies.
Please may you provide information on any funding for ‘research projects’ from ‘arms companies’ from 1 January 2017 to 5 April 2025, broken down by:
-
The title and descriptions of the project or centre and academic department(s) Involved
-
The project partners and source of funding (to be included the source of funding does not have to be an arms trade company)
-
Academic years, including the start and end date (DD-MM-YY) of the funding or project.
-
Total amount in GBP provided for each project or centre (e.g. centre for doctoral training)
-
Other participating UK universities
Thank you kindly,
Carmen
Response Text
9th June 2025
OUR REFERENCE: FOI/RFI-4337/Wilson
Dear Carmen Wilson,
Thank you for your Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) request, which we received on 13th May 2025. Your request was as follows:
We have considered your request under the FOIA and can confirm that while we hold some or all of the information requested, certain exemptions apply under the Act that prevent us from disclosing some or all of the information.
Exemptions Applied
Section 41 – Information Provided in Confidence
Section 41(1) of the Act exempts information obtained from another party if its disclosure would constitute a breach of confidence actionable by that party.
This exemption applies where:
• The information was obtained from a third party, • It has the necessary quality of confidence (i.e., not trivial or publicly available), • It was shared in circumstances giving rise to an obligation of confidence, and • Disclosure would cause detriment or otherwise breach that obligation.
In this case, some of the partnerships between the University and the listed organisations are governed by confidentiality or non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). Disclosure of specific information such as financial details, nature of research, or even confirmation of certain relationships would breach those contractual obligations.
The Obligation of Confidence
An obligation of confidence may apply if the confider has attached explicit conditions to any subsequent use or disclosure of the information (for example in the form of contractual terms).
We can confirm that the University is bound by nondisclosure agreements in relation to some of these relationships and that disclosing the existence of the relationship would itself be a breach of such contractual arrangements.
Detriment to the organisations As the withheld information is commercial in nature, disclosure will constitute a breach of confidence if it would or would be likely to have a detrimental impact on any of the organisations listed. For example, providing the details of a research project and the amount paid to the University could have a detrimental impact on the organisation through the disclosure of information that could be used by competitor organisations.
Actionable Breach of Confidence
Section 41(b) provides that the breach of confidence must be actionable by any of the organisations. Here a partner organisation could bring an action against the University for breach of confidence and breach of contract. Our view is that any work conducted under an express obligation of confidence makes a strong case that disclosure of the withheld information would amount to an actionable breach of confidence by the University. The final part of the test for engaging section 41 is whether the action for breach of confidence is likely to succeed. Our view is that legal action by any organisation for breach of confidence would be likely to succeed because the confidentiality obligations set out in the nondisclosure agreement are clear and legally binding, and we are not obliged to disclose the information under FOIA by virtue of the absolute confidentiality exemption under section 41 and the qualified exemption under section 43.
Further, disclosure would likely cause commercial detriment to those organisations—for example, by exposing sensitive research activities or funding arrangements to competitors.
Section 43(2) – Commercial Interests
Section 43(2) exempts information where disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of any party (including the University).
The information requested relates to:
• Financial arrangements,
• The University’s income sources,
• Commercial research activities, and
• Relationships with specific companies operating in a competitive global market.
Disclosure could harm the University’s ability to attract future funding or partnerships, as companies may be reluctant to work with institutions unable to maintain commercial confidentiality. It may also affect the commercial position of the organisations themselves, whose competitors could infer strategic or financial priorities from the data. Section 43 is a qualified exemption and therefore subject to the public interest test. The factors considered when deciding the public interest in disclosing the information include:
• We acknowledge that there is a public interest in understanding the sources of income that Public Authorities access and that there can be general concerns associated with the types of organisations they may enter into partnership with.
• Disclosure of information could provide a general compliance with the principles of openness and transparency and help raise awareness of the Higher Education sectors funding activities.
The factors considered when deciding the public interest in withholding the information include:
• Providing information in response to a Freedom of Information Act request is akin to publishing the information for the world to see, therefore any information released would
be considered ‘in the public domain’ and accessible to other Universities and or rival organisations of our partners.
• It is the current policy of the Government that the higher education market should be competitive in the interests of students and the wider public. As such, the Higher Education sector has become increasingly competitive, and UK Universities are now in direct competition with one another and international Universities when attempting to attract students to study at an institution. The Information Tribunal has acknowledged that universities have commercial interests (EA/2009/0034) and that UK Universities operate in a global market that sees student recruitment as a recognised commercial activity for any University
• Where the university has entered contracts that prohibit the disclosure of information within the scope of the partnerships, any breaches of confidentiality could damage future relationships with existing or future partners who may be unwilling to risk working with the UK Higher Education sector for fear of confidential information being disclosed via the FOIA. This would negatively impact both Northumbria University and the wider UK Higher Education Sector in terms of seeking future funding.
• The nature of the research would be of interest to rival organisations, nations or other Universities and could enable competitors to invest in their own areas of research. Thus, undermining the commercial interests of both the partners and the University who could lose the expected return on investment from the research.
We therefore do not believe that the public interest is served in neither confirming nor denying that the information is held or in withholding the information.
Accordingly, the requested information is exempt from disclosure under:
• Section 41 (Information Provided in Confidence), and
• Section 43(2) (Commercial Interests) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.
If you are unhappy with our response or the way your request has been handled, you have the right to ask for an internal review. To request a review, please reply to this email.
The review would be undertaken by Jay Wilson, the University’s General Counsel.
Please remember to quote the reference number above in any future communications.
Should you remain dissatisfied following an internal review, you may then appeal to the Information Commissioner at www.ico.org.uk
Yours sincerely
Duncan James
Records and Information Manager