Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, please can you provide me with the following information:
- How much money the University of Sheffield has received from arms companies (including, but not limited to, Rolls Royce, Boeing, BAE Systems), broken down both by firm and by year for each of the last ten years
- The nature of any non- or semi- financial relationships between the University and arms companies, including what connections are in place for recruitment purposes, and what research is undertaken to support the industries and/or these firms
I understand that under the Act I am entitled to a response within 20 working days of this request. Some parts of the request may be easier to answer than others (for example, getting an overall figure, or general figures taken directly from budgets etc.). Should this be the case, I request that you release any information as soon as possible.
I would like this information in an Excel spreadsheet format.
Kind regards,
<hr />(2) Dear Bethan,
-
Please could I then receive the requested information for: Rolls Royce, BAE Systems, Boeing, British Aircraft Corporation, JCB, English Electric, Vickers, Racal, Qinetiq, Selex ES, British Aerospace, Babcock International, Cobham, GKN, Chemring, Ultra Electronics, Meggitt or Thales.
-
As well as with the Careers and Research Services, please could I also request this information for members of the University Executive Board; the departments of: Automatic Control and Systems Engineering; Civil and Structural Engineering; Chemical and Biological Engineering; Computer Science; Electronic and Electrical Engineering; Mechanical Engineering; Materials Science and Engineering; as well as the Faculty of Engineering itself.
Response Refusal Reason
The University has determined that to provide the information requested relating to research funding would be likely to damage its commercial interests, both in terms of the commercial relationships it has with companies and in terms of its ability to secure research contracts in the future, and therefore that section 43(2) (prejudice to commercial interests) is engaged.
The University competes in a competitive environment for research funding, and the funding the University receives from industry and commerce forms a significant proportion of the University's research income. It is in the University's interest, and central to the successful provision of its core functions and activities of research, teaching and learning that it remains able to compete within this highly competitive commercial environment. We judge there to be a risk that disclosure of the information requested would be likely to deter companies from continuing commercial relationships with the University, or from developing commercial relationships in the future, to the detriment of the University’s core functions.
Individual project titles are often sufficiently detailed as to reveal the precise nature of the research and its applicability to the sponsors of the research. This information is likely to be of use to the competitors of the University (and the research sponsors) in pursuance of their own commercial interests. In addition, the amounts of income from the specific research sponsors are also deemed to be commercially sensitive. The commercial negotiations for research contracts will try to secure the most favourable conditions for the University and it is possible that a competitor of the University would be likely to gain a commercial advantage through suggesting that it would be capable of carrying out research within a similar area for a lower amount were this type of information divulged. The procurement of research funding takes place within a highly competitive environment, between a limited number of institutions and a limited number of research sponsors. Negotiations will have taken place within a confidential process, and there would likely have been an expectation that terms, conditions and further information such as details of the titles and those involved in the work would remain confidential unless it was agreed to release them publicly. Therefore were the University to divulge such information outside of agreed frameworks it would damage its reputation and the confidence that research sponsors have in the University. This in turn would damage the University's ability to operate fairly and equally within this competitive environment, and therefore prejudice its commercial interests.
Response Text
(1) Thank you for your request for information from the University of Sheffield.
We would be grateful for some guidance before we are able to proceed with your request.
With regards to your first point, due to the nature of how our financial information is stored, it is not possible to search our databases for companies by the nature of their business. This would include, for example, by terms such as 'engineering', or indeed 'arms companies'. In order to conduct any searches, we will require a list of business names. Could you please provide a full list of business names you would like us to search, or confirm if you are content for us to use only the 3 examples you have provided?
On your second point, we would be grateful if you could provide a further steer on which areas of the University are of interest to you. Such information may be wide-ranging, and it would not be possible for us to contact every professional services and academic department within the University (of which there are over 100) in order to determine whether they have any relationships of the nature you have defined. You have already provided the examples of any possible connections with our Careers Service and Research Services, which we will seek to provide; if you wish to add any others to this list, please advise.
Until we receive your response to the above, your request will be put on hold and our statutory deadline for disclosure is paused. As such, we look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.
All the best
--
Bethan Cook (she/her)
Data Protection Assistant
University Secretary's Office
The University of Sheffield
First Floor
Arts Tower
12 Bolsover Street
Sheffield
S3 7NA
Email: [email protected]
Web: https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/uso
<hr />(2) Thank you for providing clarification of the companies and areas of the University you are interested in.
Please see our response to your request attached ('01 Request Response', '02 Values' and '03 Faculty of Engineering'). Q1: Please see separate attached spreadsheet titled ‘Values’ detailing the money received by the University from the companies listed above by academic year.
Q2.1: None of the members of the University Executive Board advised us that they have a “non- or semifinancial” relationship with any of the companies listed above. Members of the University Executive Board are listed here: https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/ueb/teamprofiles 2.2 Careers Service (see table in response file) 2.3 Please see separate attached spreadsheet titled ‘Faculty of Engineering’. 2.4 Research Services (exemption applied)
If you are not satisfied with the University's response to your FOI request, please see details of our internal review process here, including details of how to contact the Information Commissioner's Office for an independent review.
Best wishes
Elspeth
--
Elspeth Summerfield
Assistant Data Protection Officer
University Secretary's Office
The University of Sheffield
First Floor
Arts Tower
12 Bolsover Street
Sheffield
S3 7NA