See how much your university is linked to the arms trade →

Freedom of Information (FoI) Request

Request Date
13 Dec, 2022
Response Date
16 Dec, 2022
Provision
Fully or partially refused

See the refusal reason.

Military Links
Unknown

Request Text

To Whom it may concern,

I am writing this request following up from a request made on the 21/11/2022, which is copied below:

To whom it may concern,

Under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, please can you provide me with the following information:

  • How much money the University of Sheffield has received from arms companies (including, but not limited to, Rolls Royce, Boeing, BAE Systems), broken down both by firm and by year for each of the last ten years
  • The nature of any non- or semi- financial relationships between the University and arms companies, including what connections are in place for recruitment purposes, and what research is undertaken to support the industries and/or these firms

I understand that under the Act I am entitled to a response within 20 working days of this request. Some parts of the request may be easier to answer than others (for example, getting an overall figure, or general figures taken directly from budgets etc.). Should this be the case, I request that you release any information as soon as possible.

I would like this information in an Excel spreadsheet format.

I understand that under the Act I am entitled to a response within 20 working days of this request. Some parts of the request may be easier to answer than others (for example, getting an overall figure, or general figures taken directly from budgets etc.). Should this be the case, I request that you release any information as soon as possible.

You responded very clearly, and efficiently, which I appreciate greatly. I was just wondering if I could request further details for the 1st information request. You provided the amount of money from by each arms company in an Excel spreadsheet, but could you please provide the reason for each of these payments, i.e. consultancy fees, research project, endowment donation etc.

Many thanks,

Millie

Response Refusal Reason

(1) Section 1(1) does not oblige a public authority to comply with a request for information if the authority estimates that the cost of complying with the request would exceed the appropriate limit. For public authorities in the UK, the appropriate limit is up to 18 hours of work, or £450 at £25 an hour, on one request. This information is given in the Freedom of Information (Fees and Appropriate Limit) Regulations 2004.

Response Text

Dear Millie

Thank you for your request for information from the University of Sheffield.

We have considered your request carefully and estimate that we will not be able to provide the information requested without exceeding the 'appropriate limit'. We therefore engage section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000:

*Section 12 – Exemption where cost of compliance exceeds appropriate limit

(1) Section 1(1) does not oblige a public authority to comply with a request for information if the authority estimates that the cost of complying with the request would exceed the appropriate limit.*

For public authorities in the UK, the appropriate limit is up to 18 hours of work, or £450 at £25 an hour, on one request. This information is given in the Freedom of Information (Fees and Appropriate Limit) Regulations 2004.

In relation to your request, details of the payments received, collated in the spreadsheet you make reference to, span over 70 records and some 2,500 invoices. In order to determine the nature of each payment, colleagues would be required to individually review and assess each of these invoices. Unfortunately, we estimate that the time needed to complete this for each year you have requested would exceed the appropriate limit. At a reasonable estimate of 5 minutes to review and assess each invoice, 2,500 invoices would take over 208 hours to review and collate.

In accordance with section 16 of the Freedom of Information Act, we are happy to look at ways you can refine your request in order to have access to some of the information you have requested. If you would like to look at refining your request, please let us know.

If you are not satisfied with the University's response to your FOI request, please see details of our internal review process here, including details of how to contact the Information Commissioner's Office for an independent review.

Kind regards

Rob

<hr />

Dear Rob,

Thank you for your reply but I am slightly confused. What I find hard to understand is how you have already given all the information, as you say, "which span over 70 records and some 2,500 invoices”, but cannot provide the reasoning behind the payments for these invoices within the 18 hour time limit?

I’d like to clarify my request also, and apologise if I was not clear in the initial request. I am only looking for the specific reasoning behind the invoices you have provided in the Excel spreadsheet, which is 79 invoices. By your calculation of 5 minutes per invoice that is only 395 minutes, or 6.59 hours - less than the appropriate limit of 18 hours of work per request.

To make it more manageable for your team if still required after this clarification, you could limit the financial years to the last five. By the previous information given, that is only 35 invoices, so 175 minutes or 2.95 hours.

I’ve attached the previous response and the spread sheet that you have previously made for the first request to try and make it clear what I’m referencing too.

Any explanation would be helpful.

Many thanks

Millie

<hr />

Dear Millie

I apologise for any confusion, but it does appear there has been a misunderstanding.

Whilst there are 79 separate sums on the spreadsheet you provided, this is because the original request asked us to provide the money received from each company, separated by financial year, as a whole. Each of these sums will be held as a separate record, hence our statement that over 70 records are encompassed by your request; as you have calculated, there are 79 different records that would need to be reviewed. However, each of these 79 sums are extremely unlikely to have been received in one payment or with regards to one matter, and each of the 79 sums provided likely comprise tens or hundreds of different invoices. It was on investigation of the 79 associated records in question that colleagues determined that there are around 2,500 invoices associated with these records in total.

As previously stated, in order to determine the nature of each payment, colleagues would be required to individually review and assess each of these invoices. Even by limiting the the data provided to over the last 5 financial years, some 100 hours of time would be accrued in order to review over 1,000 invoices, and we are therefore unable to refine your request in this manner.

Kind regards

Bethan

Data sources

Source

This is an FoI request submitted by dED staff