Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Thank you for your assistance with my previous requests. In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
This includes, and if necessary, to fit within the time/cost limitations, can be limited to:
- BAE Systems
- Babcock
- QinetiQ
- Rolls-Royce
- Serco
- Cobham
- Raytheon (RTX)
- Airbus
- General Dynamics
- Leonardo MW
- Lockheed Martin
- Thales
- MBDA
- Elbit Systems
- Northrop Grumman
- L3 Harris Technologies
- General Electric
- AVIC
- GKN Aerospace
- Boeing
- Ministry of Defence (MoD)
- Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl)
- Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
‘Academic partnerships’ refers to arms company involvement (funder or partner) in any of the following:
- Apprenticeships and graduate schemes
- Job advertisements and career fair appearances
- Sponsorships (events, workshops, trainings)
- Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships
- Department funding and relationships (e.g. knowledge transfer relationships)
- Consultancy and executive roles
Can the university please provide any relevant information or evidence of arms companies' involvement in any of the capacities mentioned above over the past eight years?
Please may this be broken down by:
- Academic year and with the start/end date (DD-MM-YY) where applicable
- The name of the arms company involved and the nature of the partnership (partnership, collaboration, consultancy, funding)
- The financial value of the relationship in pounds sterling
- The name(s) of the academic department(s) involved
- The name and description of the degree and/or research being conducted in the studentship
*Notes to FOI Officer:
The timeframe for this request should cover 1 January 2017 to 5 April 2025, or the University’s reporting period (1 August 2017 to 31 July 2025), up to the most recent completed year. Should the above request exceed the time/cost limitations outlined in Section 12 of the FOIA, please consider the list of 23 entities as a complete list. If necessary, limit the timeframe to 5 financial years and restrict the scope to data held centrally by the university.
Please indicate in the response whether the full scope was considered or the narrowed criteria (23 entities only, and if a limited time frame).
Kind regards,
Carmen
------------------------------------------------------------------------
follow-up request
To whom it may concern,
Thank you kindly for your response and advice on narrowing my request. I would like to please accept your advice
and reduce the timeframe of my request to one year.
Kind regards,
Carmen
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2nd follow-up request
Thank you for you reply. In order to make the best requests in the future, would you be able to please provide where the information is stored related to each category? For example,
· Apprenticeships and graduate schemes (by academic department) · Job advertisements and career fair appearances (Careers & Enterprise Centre) · Sponsorships of events, workshops, and trainings
Executive roles (publicly listed on website only
Response Refusal Reason
s.12 (2) of the Freedom of Information Act is engaged (Cost limit).
Section 43(2) – Commercial interests, particularly in relation to funding agreements and sponsorships, where disclosure could prejudice the legitimate interests of the University or third parties.
Section 41 – Information provided in confidence, which may apply to certain partnership arrangements and funding details.
Response Text
Dear Requester
Thank you for your request for information from Durham University. Colleagues have provided the information below in response to your questions.
In accordance with Section 17(5) this letter acts as a Refusal Notice for Durham University to comply with Section 1 (1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Unfortunately, your request exceeds the fees limit, in that in order to ascertain whether Durham University holds all the information requested would require an extensive search of the relevant documents.
Section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act provides an exemption from a public authority’s obligation to comply with a request for information where the cost of compliance is estimated to exceed the appropriate limit. Section 12 – the legislation:
The provisions of section 12(2) of the Act is engaged in response to your request as Durham University are unable to confirm what information it might hold in relation to your request because to do so would exceed the ‘appropriate limit’ – i.e. the cost limit. Section 12 of the Act: Section 1(1) does not oblige a public authority to comply with a request for information if the authority estimates that the cost of complying with the request would exceed the appropriate limit. (2) Subsection (1) does not exempt the public authority from its obligation to comply with paragraph (a) of section 1(1) unless the estimated cost of complying with that paragraph alone would exceed the appropriate limit.
These sections of the Act state Durham University is not obliged to comply with its duties under section 1(1) of the Act – i.e. our duty to confirm or deny what information is or is not held, and to supply any information held in response to a request – if to do so would exceed the ‘appropriate limit’.
The ‘appropriate limit’ is defined in the Freedom of Information (Appropriate Limit and Fees) Regulations 2004. Section 3 and 4 of those regulations provide that an authority can take into account the costs it reasonably expects to incur in relation to a Freedom of Information request to the following four activities associated with handling that request:
(a) Determining whether or not it holds the information (b) Locating that information, or document(s) which might contain the information (c) Retrieving the information, and (d) Extracting the information from a document containing it. The regulations then confirm that the appropriate limit
(in the case of a body such as the as a University) is £450 and that any work estimated or carried out in respect of the above four activities is to be estimated at a rate of £25 per hour.
In accordance with Section 16 (1) of the Freedom of Information Act a public authority is obliged to provide advice and assistance, so far as it is reasonable to expect the authority to do so, to persons who propose to make, or have made, requests for information.
In this instance to ascertain ‘all information held’ searches would involve the following:-
- Assess each confidentiality provision against the requested information, to determine if the agreement/contract terms might prevent disclosure.
a. Each specific request typically needs assessment and interpretation on a case-by-case basis, and it is not always evident for each aspect of the requested information as to whether the other party would deem the requested information confidential. Arguably the mere existence of an agreement is confidential to some organisations, particularly defence companies. Companies tend to look at the request as a whole and how they might be perceived in light of the context. We also factor in the risk of not consulting the industry partner, in accordance with the contract conditions.
It’s estimated this step could take up to one hour per individual case.
- The next step would be:-
a. Attempt to source a relevant contact at the industry partner/organisation and write to them, to
i. inform them of the exact request/requester, ii. discuss the implications of the contract and confidentiality provisions, iii. request their review and approval (to disclose the request information
contained in the related contracts).
b. Write to the relevant academic/department, to
i. inform them of the exact request, ii. discuss the implications of the contract and confidentiality provisions, iii. obtain an understanding of the confidential nature of the requested
information,
iv. request their review and approval (to disclose the request information contained in the related contracts).
It is estimated that this step may take up to one hour per contract.
- The next step would be:- a. Information Governance would offer advice and conduct a Public Interest Test where necessary,
This step is estimated to take two hours per contract
- Bearing in mind the time period to search for this information is almost 8 years this would increase the total time taken considerably and reaches the cost limit much sooner.
The university may be able to disclose some of the requested information if you are prepared to narrow the scope of your request, we would suggest you resubmit requesting this request for a period of one year. However, we cannot confirm at this stage if this would bring your request under the appropriate limit, or that another exemption will not apply.
If you are dissatisfied with the University’s response to your freedom of information request, you can ask us to internally review our handling of your request, including the application of any exemptions applied.
To do this, please email [email protected].
Please state the grounds on which you wish the decision to be reviewed and enclose any other information that may be useful in considering the matter further. We aim to inform you of our decision within 20 working days from the date your request for internal review is received. If you are not satisfied with the results of the internal review you may apply to the Information Commissioner's Office for an independent review.
Information Commissioner's Office
Wycliffe House
Water Lane
Wilmslow
Cheshire
SK9 5AF
www.ico.org.uk
Yours sincerely
Information Governance Unit Durham University
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
follow-up response
Dear Requester
Thank you for your request for information from Durham University. Colleagues have provided the information below/attached in response to your questions.
Request:
Thank you kindly for your response and advice on narrowing my request. I would like to please accept your advice and reduce the timeframe of my request to one year.
Response:
We have considered your request under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. After careful review, we regret to inform you that we are unable to comply with your request as it would exceed the appropriate cost limit set out in Section 12 of the Act.
Under Section 12, public authorities are not obliged to comply with a request if the estimated cost of determining whether the information is held, locating, retrieving, and extracting it would exceed £450 (equivalent to 18 hours of staff time at £25 per hour). In this case, the scope and breadth of the request—particularly in relation to multiple types of partnerships and activities—would require extensive searches across various departments and systems, many of which are not centrally coordinated or recorded in a way that would allow efficient retrieval.
Additionally, even if the request were narrowed, we believe that much of the information would still be subject to exemptions previously applied, including:
- Section 43(2) – Commercial interests, particularly in relation to funding agreements and sponsorships, where disclosure could prejudice the legitimate interests of the University or third parties.
- Section 41 – Information provided in confidence, which may apply to certain partnership arrangements and funding details.
It is also important to note that some areas of your request would require searches outside of our Research Department these are:
Apprenticeships and graduate schemes
Job advertisements and career fair appearances
Sponsorships of events, workshops, and trainings
Departmental funding and relationships (e.g. knowledge transfer partnerships – none currently exist with the named companies)
Executive roles
These would require coordination with multiple other departments, further contributing to the cost and complexity of the response.
You may wish to consider refining your request to focus on a specific area or partnership type although it cannot be guaranteed that that request could be answered within the prescribed time limit.
It may be of interest to you to know that If the University has any KTPs or funded PhD studentships with these organisations they would be published on GtR.
Please note that universities operate independently and utilise a wide range of systems, processes, and structures tailored to their specific institutional needs. As such, the information provided in this response reflects Durham University's unique context and may not be directly comparable to data or practices at other institutions.
Any comparisons should be made with caution, taking into account these differences.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2nd follow-up response
Dear Requester
Thank you for your request for information from Durham University. Colleagues have provided the information below/attached in response to your questions.
Request:
Thank you for you reply. In order to make the best requests in the future, would you be able to please provide where the information is stored related to each category? For example,
· Apprenticeships and graduate schemes (by academic department) · Job advertisements and career fair appearances (Careers & Enterprise Centre) · Sponsorships of events, workshops, and trainings Executive roles (publicly listed on website only
Response:
The information you have requested is not held centrally, and as such s.12 (2) of the Freedom of Information Act is engaged (Cost limit).
Business owners have confirmed that this information is not held centrally, and to provide a response would require every individual department and careers service departments to investigate student files and historic records, where held. Therefore it is estimated that the time taken to locate, retrieve and extract the requested information would exceed the fees limit associated with the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA). Under Section 12 of the FOIA, the University is not obliged to comply with a request for information if the cost of compliance would exceed a £450 threshold, a figure which equates to approximately 18 hours of work spent searching/retrieving and extracting requested information.
You may wish to consider narrowing your request to bring it within the cost limit. The only suggestion that can be made is that you specifiy a specific academic department you are interested in and we could ascertain if that refined request could be answered (subject to any relevant exemption).
Please note that universities operate independently and utilise a wide range of systems, processes, and structures tailored to their specific institutional needs. As such, the information provided in this response reflects Durham University's unique context and may not be directly comparable to data or practices at other institutions. Any comparisons should be made with caution, taking into account these differences.
If you are dissatisfied with the University’s response to your freedom of information request, you can ask us to internally review our handling of your request, including the application of any exemptions applied. This must be within 40 working days from the date of our response to you. To do this, please email [email protected]. Please state the grounds on which you wish the decision to be reviewed and enclose any other information that may be useful in considering the matter further. We aim to inform you of our decision within 20 working days from the date your request for internal review is received. If you are not satisfied with the results of the internal review you may apply to the Information Commissioner's Office for an independent review.
Information Commissioner's Office
Wycliffe House
Water Lane
Wilmslow
Cheshire
SK9 5AF
www.ico.org.uk
Yours sincerely
Information Governance Unit
Durham University