Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Thank you for your assistance with my previous requests. In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
This includes, and if necessary, to fit within the time/cost limitations, can be limited to:
- BAE Systems
- Babcock
- QinetiQ
- Rolls-Royce
- Serco
- Cobham
- Raytheon (RTX)
- Airbus
- General Dynamics
- Leonardo MW
- Lockheed Martin
- Thales
- MBDA
- Elbit Systems
- Northrop Grumman
- L3 Harris Technologies
- General Electric
- AVIC
- GKN Aerospace
- Boeing
- Ministry of Defence (MoD)
- Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl)
- Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
‘Academic partnerships’ refers to arms company involvement (funder or partner) in any of the following:
- Apprenticeships and graduate schemes
- Job advertisements and career fair appearances
- Sponsorships (events, workshops, trainings)
- Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships
- Department funding and relationships (e.g. knowledge transfer relationships)
- Consultancy and executive roles
Can the university please provide any relevant information or evidence of arms companies' involvement in any of the capacities mentioned above over the past eight years?
Please may this be broken down by:
- Academic year and with the start/end date (DD-MM-YY) where applicable
- The name of the arms company involved and the nature of the partnership (partnership, collaboration, consultancy, funding)
- The financial value of the relationship in pounds sterling
- The name(s) of the academic department(s) involved
- The name and description of the degree and/or research being conducted in the studentship
*Notes to FOI Officer:
The timeframe for this request should cover 1 January 2017 to 5 April 2025, or the University’s reporting period (1 August 2017 to 31 July 2025), up to the most recent completed year. Should the above request exceed the time/cost limitations outlined in Section 12 of the FOIA, please consider the list of 23 entities as a complete list. If necessary, limit the timeframe to 5 financial years and restrict the scope to data held centrally by the university.
Please indicate in the response whether the full scope was considered or the narrowed criteria (23 entities only, and if a limited time frame).
Kind regards,
Carmen
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow-up Request
Hello,
Thank you for your response and advice. I would like to narrow my request using your advice to a timeframe of three years.
Could you also please advise if I were to ask for information within each academic department, if this would be better?
Kind regards,
Carmen
Response Refusal Reason
Section 40(2) – Personal data
Section 12 – Exceeds the appropriate time/cost limit
Section 24(1) – National security
Section 26(1)(a) & (b) – Defence
Section 43(2) – Commercial interests
Response Text
Dear Carmen,
Ref: FOI/25/171
Further to your request for information, please find the University's response below.
Section 12
The University is unable to provide the requested information for the time period 1 January 2017 to 5 April 2025 as a breakdown of this data for these years is not held in a centralised manner; to locate, retrieve and extract the requested information would require manual scrutiny of hundreds of individual records, which would take in excess of the ‘appropriate limit’ set out at Section 12 of the FOI Act, being the equivalent of 18 hours. We would suggest limiting the search period requested to 3 years in total.
Best wishes,
Legal & Information Compliance Team
Freedom of Information
Legal & Information Compliance
Keele University | Staffordshire | ST5 5BG | www.keele.ac.uk
Email: [email protected]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Attachment
-
Vacancy advert – Ministry of Defence
- Employer: Ministry of Defence
- Graduate Recruitment Programme: No
- Position: Defence STEM Undergraduate Sponsorship Scheme
- Number of positions:
- Expiry Date: 11-Aug-2024
-
Added: 23-Jul-2024
-
Hours: Temporary Full Time
- Location:
- City:
- Country: United Kingdom
- Payrate: £9,250 each year + £5,000 bursary
-
Summary:
The Defence STEM Undergraduate Sponsorship (DSUS) scheme will provide you with full financial support whilst you complete your university studies. In addition, you will be given the opportunity of permanent employment within the Engineering profession following your graduation. This fantastic scheme is open to anyone studying a STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Maths) subject. -
Details:
Do you want to be at the heart of real Defence issues and play a key role in the United Kingdom’s (UK) national security? Are you interested in starting your career in Engineering? The Defence Nuclear Enterprise (DNE) delivers nuclear capability to deter threats and protect our nation and is made up of several organisations, programmes and people that sustain the UK’s nuclear deterrent. Core organisations are the Defence Nuclear Organisation, Royal Navy, Submarine Delivery Agency and the Atomic Weapons Establishment - as well as those in other parts of the Ministry of Defence and principal Industry partners including Rolls-Royce, BAE Systems and Babcock Marine.The UK’s independent nuclear deterrent has existed for over 60 years to deter the most extreme threats to our national security and way of life, and that of our NATO Allies. To ensure that we have a credible and capable nuclear deterrent for as long as the security situation requires, we are building four new nuclear armed submarines – known as the Dreadnought Class – and replacing our nuclear warheads.
The DNE strongly believes that diversity and inclusion is not only the right thing to do but is also essential for a thriving and successful organisation. We know that diverse teams bring a wide range of perspectives, experiences and ideas, which lead to better decision-making, creativity and innovation. We have a culture where differences are celebrated and our people feel supported, included and empowered. Join us and be part of an organisation that truly values diversity and inclusion and makes a positive impact on the world.
The Defence STEM Undergraduate Sponsorship (DSUS) scheme will provide you with full financial support whilst you complete your university studies. In addition, you will be given the opportunity of permanent employment within the Engineering profession following your graduation. This fantastic scheme is open to anyone studying a STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Maths) subject.
Not only does the scheme cover the cost of your tuition fees and pay a bursary each year, but you’ll have the opportunity to undertake a 45-day paid work placement over the summer each year for up to three years.
Please be aware that you must be a UK National to apply. You must also be able to obtain and maintain the necessary security clearance to work for the SDA. -
Job description – Sponsorship Offer:
If you are accepted onto this scheme, whilst you study for your degree, we will:
• Pay your tuition fees (up to £9,250 each year)
• Pay you a bursary of £5,000 each year*
• Organise 45 days paid work placements
• Offer permanent employment following your graduationSummer placements are crafted to give you experience of the DNE. They will enable you to work on real Defence projects with real responsibility, while benefiting from a wide support network, which will be of value to your professional development and future career. Generally, they are organised in Bristol.
Placements provide an overview of the projects undertaken within MOD delivery teams, this may be working on optioneering documents, risk assessments or technical research reports. Your summer placements will build exposure to both MOD ways of working, the relevant classes of vessels, engineering lifecycle activities and delivery team structures – this will ultimately aid you upon entering the business.
Placements are organised in July and August and you will be contracted to work 37 hours per week as an Administrator Officer (AO) (current minimum £24,985.00 pro rata). As an MOD employee, you are also entitled to 5 days paid annual leave which is applied to the end of the placement.
• Travel and accommodation claims will not be reimbursed by the department.
• Not applicable during industrial placement year or candidates in their final year of study.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Follow-up Response
- Apprenticeships and graduate schemes; Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships Two student apprenticeships began and/or completed within the relevant timeframe; further detail is withheld by virtue of Sections 24, 26, 40 and 43 of the FOI Act, please see below for further details.
- .Job advertisements and career fair appearances One vacancy advert, please see attached.
- .Sponsorships (events, workshops, trainings) The requested information is not held.
- Department funding and relationships (e.g. knowledge transfer relationships) The requested information is not held.
- Consultancy and executive roles The requested information is not held. Withheld Information
The requested information is withheld by virtue of Sections 24, 26, 40 and 43 of the FOI Act. Section 24(1), National Security and Section 26(1)(a) and (b), Defence: a release of data under the FOI Act is considered a release to 'the world at large'. When aggregated and assimilated over time, release of data related to defence studies would provide UK adversaries with a rich picture of defence interest and capability due to the mosaic effect, thereby undermining the safeguarding of national security of the UK and prejudicing the defence of the nation and the effectiveness of national forces. These are qualified exemptions and the public interest test applies. Section 40(2)(3A)(a), Personal Information: disclosure of the requested information would reveal identifiable personal information of students, which would contravene one or more of the data protection principles. This is an absolute exemption and the public interest test does not apply.
Section 43(2), Commercial Interests: disclosure of the requested information would prejudice the University's commercial interests in relation to its ability to secure funding for learning and teaching activities. Release of data under the FOI Act is considered a release to 'the world at large', disclosure of the commercial aspects of academic partnerships would provide valuable information to competitors within the increasingly marketised sector of higher education, which would be used to undermine the University in this area. Release would likely also have a chilling effect on potential partnerships, further undermining the University's ability to secure funding for its learning and teaching activities. This is qualified exemption and the public interest test applies. Public Interest Test Factors favouring release: disclosure would provide the public with insight into defence-related studies.
Factors against release: aggregation of information over time is considered a valuable source of intelligence to UK adversaries, both as ‘building block’ material and also in regards to current and future UK defence critical assets and capabilities; such intelligence would contribute to hostile actions against the UK and its people.
The University is a centre for economic growth and cultural vibrancy both within the region and nationally, providing advancements in society through its world-leading research contributions and via the enrichment of its students through knowledge and experience.
Disclosure of commercially sensitive
information would undermine this provision by negatively affecting the University's ability to secure funding fairly and therefore impact its ability ro carry out day-to-day activities. Outcome: on balance, it has been determined that the public interest lies in withholding the requested information.
Should you have any queries, please don't hesitate to get in touch.
Best wishes,
Legal & Information Compliance Team