Freedom of Information (FoI) Request
See the refusal reason.
Request Text
To whom it may concern,
Thank you for your assistance with my previous requests.
In the below request, the phrase ‘arms trade companies' relates to any company on the SIPRI Top 100 arms-producing companies and Defence News Top 100 lists.
This includes, and if necessary, to fit within the time/cost limitations, can be limited to:
BAE Systems
Babcock
QinetiQ
Rolls-Royce
Serco
Cobham
Raytheon (RTX)
Airbus
General Dynamics
Leonardo MW
Lockheed Martin
Thales
MBDA
Elbit Systems
Northrop Grumman
L3 Harris Technologies
General Electric
AVIC
GKN Aerospace
Boeing
Ministry of Defence (MoD)
Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl)
Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE)
‘Academic partnerships’ refers to arms company involvement (funder or partner) in any of the following:
Apprenticeships and graduate schemes
Job advertisements and career fair appearances
Sponsorships (events, workshops, trainings)
Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships
Department funding and relationships (e.g. knowledge transfer relationships)
Consultancy and executive roles
Can the university please provide any relevant information or evidence of arms companies' involvement in any of the capacities mentioned above over the past eight years?
Please may this be broken down by:
Academic year and with the start/end date (DD-MM-YY) where applicable
The name of the arms company involved and the nature of the partnership (partnership, collaboration, consultancy, funding)
The financial value of the relationship in pounds sterling
The name(s) of the academic department(s) involved
The name and description of the degree and/or research being conducted in the studentship
*Notes to FOI Officer:
The timeframe for this request should cover 1 January 2017 to 5 April 2025, or the University’s reporting period (1 August 2017 to 31 July 2025), up to the most recent completed year.
Should the above request exceed the time/cost limitations outlined in Section 12 of the FOIA, please consider the list of 23 entities as a complete list. If necessary, limit the timeframe to 5 financial years and restrict the scope to data held centrally by the university.
Please indicate in the response whether the full scope was considered or the narrowed criteria (23 entities only, and if a limited time frame).
Kind regards,
Carmen
Narrowed Request:
Thank you for getting back to me. Can you please confirm if a limited scope of 23 entities and 5 years still exceeds the time/cost limitations? If so, please narrow the request further to 2 years and limit the search to the following categories:
Apprenticeships and graduate schemes Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships Consultancy and executive roles
Second Narrowed Reply:
Thank you for the clarification. To make the request more achievable, please narrow the scope to the Faculty of Science, Agriculture and Engineering, specifically the following schools:
- School of Computing
- School of Engineering
- School of Mathematics, Statistics and Physics
- School of Natural and Environmental Sciences
Response Refusal Reason
Initially rejected under Section 12 for exceeding the time/cost limitations, then given the narrowed scope of the request, some information was exempt under Sections 43(2) and 41.
Response Text
Initial Rejection under Section 12:
We are currently considering your request under Section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, which allows public authorities to refuse a request if complying would exceed the appropriate cost limit. For universities, this limit is set at £450, which equates to 18 hours of staff time. Having reviewed the scope of your request, we consider it to be broad in nature. The information you have asked for is not held in a centralised location and would require extensive searches across multiple departments, systems, and records. Due to the dispersed nature of the information and the time required to locate, retrieve, and extract the relevant data, we estimate that the cost of compliance would exceed the appropriate limit.
Advice and Guidance
If you are able to narrow the scope of your request to a specific area within the University and submit this as a new request we may be able to facilitate this.
Response to Narrowed Request:
Thank you for your revised request.
We note your proposal to limit the scope to 23 entities and 5 years, and further narrow the categories to:
Apprenticeships and graduate schemes Studentships, sponsored PhDs, scholarships and professorships Consultancy and executive roles
As previously advised, the University does not hold this information in a centralised format. Records relating to these categories are likely to be held, if at all, within individual schools or departments, each of which may maintain data differently. Therefore, even with the reduced scope, the time and cost required to identify, locate, and extract the relevant information across all 23 entities and over a 5-year period would still exceed the appropriate limit under Section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.
We acknowledge your further suggestion to limit the timeframe to 2 years. To make the request more achievable, we would recommend narrowing the scope to a small number of specific schools or departments where you believe the information is most likely to be held. This would allow us to assess whether the request could be fulfilled within the cost limit.
Please let us know which schools or departments you would like us to focus on, and we will be happy to consider the revised request.
Final Reply with Data:
Our response
We have contacted the Teams we would reasonable expect to hold this information and have not identified any apprenticeships/graduate schemes/sponsored Phd’s/scholarships/professorships/executive roles between these companies and the faculty of Science, Agriculture and Engineering.
We have conducted searches and located the following information relevant to your request. Please note that while this represents all the data we have been able to identify within the Section 12 cost limit, it may not include every piece of information held by the University. This is because the Act allows us to limit the time spent on locating and retrieving information to avoid exceeding the statutory cost threshold.
Studentships:
Company - School - Research - Start date - End Date - Amount Received GBP (2023-2025)
Airbus Defence and Space Ltd - School of Engineering Smart Earth Observation Satellite - 01/10/2024 - 30/09/2028 - (£) Section 43 and Section 41
Airbus Defence and Space Ltd - School of Computing - Context Aware AI techniques for Secure and Tamper-proof Satellite Image Distribution - 18/09/2023 - 17/09/2027 - Section 43 and Section 41
Defence Science and Technology Laboratory DSTL - School of Engineering - Digital Twins and their Support to Data Science in Defence - 23/01/2019 - 22/09/2023 - £78,060.00
Consultancy:
This data relates to where invoices have been paid under the category of consultancy in our Finance System.
Company - School - Amount Received GBP (2023-2025)
Leonardo UK Limited - Faculty of Science, Agriculture and Engineering - Section 43
Some information has been withheld under the following exemptions:
Section 43(2) – Commercial Interests
Disclosure of certain values would be likely to prejudice the commercial interests of our partner organisation.
Public Interest Test:
We recognise that there is a public interest in transparency and accountability in the use of public funds and partnerships. However, releasing this information could harm the competitive position of the partner organisation and damage future commercial negotiations, which would not be in the public interest. On balance, we consider that the public interest in withholding this information outweighs the public interest in disclosure.
Section 41 – Information Provided in Confidence
Some information is subject to contractual confidentiality clauses. Disclosure would constitute an actionable breach of confidence, and this exemption is absolute (no public interest test applies).